Just like the Firefox browser, the Brave browser is free, open source and focused on protecting users’ privacy. Brave is a relative newcomer to the world of browsers: its maker, Brave Software, first debuted the browser in January 2016. In this article we’ll compare our Firefox browser with the Brave browser in three categories: privacy, utility and portability.
Security and Privacy
Security and Privacy | ||
---|---|---|
Private Browsing mode | ||
Blocks third-party tracking cookies by default | ||
Blocks cryptomining scripts | ||
Blocks social trackers |
The Brave browser, like so many others, is built on the open-source Chromium code by Google. Open-source means anyone can use the source code and piggy-back on top of it to build whatever they want — like the Opera and Edge browsers. But it doesn’t mean that all Chromium-based browsers are equal or are themselves open source.
Brave differentiates itself from the other Chromium browsers by focusing on user privacy — specifically by blocking trackers, scripts, and ads by default. So when you use the Brave browser, the areas of a website that would normally display ads appear as blank spaces. In some instances, pages don’t load properly, which will require you to either choose a different browser or flip the ‘Shields Up’ setting to ‘Shields Down’ which turns off the privacy and security protection.
The Internet as a whole is largely paid for by display advertisem*nts, which keeps the actual content you want to view free. Brave has attempted to upend this model by encouraging its users to opt into Brave’s own reward system, which in reality, is its own ad platform. Once a user has opted-in, Brave will display what they call “privacy-respecting ads” for which you can view and earn what they call a Basic Attention Token a.k.a. a BAT. From this point Brave users can choose to spend their BATs on supporting the sites or individual contributors they love, who in turn can convert the BATs into actual currency.
Whether this sounds complicated or like a great idea, probably depends on your level of contempt for the display advertising on the Internet. Most Internet users understand that good content costs money, and are okay with the fact that the money comes from advertising.
On the other side of the coin, with the Firefox browser, we prefer to keep things simple. Firefox blocks many third party trackers, cryptominers and fingerprinting trackers from following you by default. However, Firefox, outside of Private Browsing Mode, chooses not to block display ads from appearing. That is, unless you install one of the extensions specifically designed for that purpose.
There are a few security features in Brave worth highlighting, such as its automatic HTTPS connection upgrades (which Firefox also offers by extension). Brave and Firefox both offer users a native password manager and the ability to check their security statistics anytime. Brave displays stats like the number of trackers it has blocked whenever you open a new tab. Firefox displays similar information when you view your privacy report which can be accessed anytime by clicking the shield in the address bar.
The bottom line is that even though Brave’s revenue model with the Basic Attention Tokens may be too complex for a lot of users, overall both Brave and Firefox browsers offer a variety of ways to enjoy a safe and private browsing experience.
Download Firefox Browser
- Desktop
- Android
- iOS
Utility
Utility | ||
---|---|---|
Autoplay blocking | ||
Tab browsing | ||
Bookmark manager | ||
Automatically fills out forms | ||
Search engine options | ||
Text to speech | ||
Reader mode | ||
Spell checking | ||
Web extensions/Add-ons | ||
In-browser screenshot tool |
What might surprise some new Brave users is just how fast pages tend to load in the browser. The reason for these speedy load times is that pages load much quicker when you block all of the advertising on them. There’s simply less to load so it takes less time.
In terms of actual precious RAM usage, the Brave browser is much heavier than Firefox. Brave comes pre-loaded with various features and “add-ons” which can be attributed to its usage of more RAM. Firefox, on the other hand, lets you decide which add-ons and extensions you want to bolt on.
Customization of UI elements and themes have been a favorite feature of Firefox users for years and our avid community of developers have created a vast library of open source add-ons and extensions allowing for even more personalization and functionality. Features that come with Firefox when you download include our powerful screenshots tool, accessibility features and integration with Pocket — a resource that lets users quickly save an article for later reading on any device.
Brave also supports the huge library of extensions available in the Google Chrome web store and offers a variety of in-browser features like the aforementioned Brave Rewards program, and support for downloading torrents in the browser.
Portability
Portability | ||
---|---|---|
OS availability | ||
Mobile OS availability | ||
Syncs with mobile | ||
Password management | ||
Primary password |
The ability to sync your passwords, extensions, form data, add-ons and other preferences across all your devices and operating systems is a feature that’s been available for years with Firefox. The synced data is also encrypted, which means no one can access it from the outside.
The Firefox browser also gives users the ability to sign up for a free Mozilla account. Having a Mozilla account is the key to unlocking syncing across devices, plus you get the added benefit of products like Firefox Monitor which monitors your email addresses and alerts you if any of your information has been involved in any known data breaches.
Brave also recently gained the ability to sync data across most popular operating systems and devices as well with the added capability of syncing your Basic Attention Tokens.
Download Firefox Browser
- Desktop
- Android
- iOS
Overall Assessment
When comparing the two browsers, both Firefox and Brave offer a sophisticated level of privacy and security by default, available automatically from the very first time you open them.
Brave’s advertising replacement idea is a twist on the current model of paid ad placement and paid search. But again, some busy Internet users will probably not want to get too involved with the management of micro payments to sites in exchange for their time and attention.
Overall, Brave is a fast and secure browser that will have particular appeal to cryptocurrency users. But for the vast majority of internet citizens, Firefox remains a better and simpler solution.
The comparisons made here were done so with default settings and across browser release versions as follows:
Firefox (81) | Brave (1.14.81)
This page is updated semi-quarterly to reflect latest versioning and may not always reflect latest updates.
As an expert in the field of web browsers and online privacy, my deep understanding of the intricacies involved in browser technologies allows me to provide an insightful analysis of the article comparing the Firefox and Brave browsers. Let's delve into the key concepts mentioned in the article:
-
Security and Privacy:
- Private Browsing Mode:
- Both Firefox and Brave offer a private browsing mode, ensuring that user data is not stored locally.
- Blocking Features:
- Both browsers block third-party tracking cookies, cryptomining scripts, and social trackers by default.
- Brave, based on the open-source Chromium code, focuses on user privacy by default, distinguishing itself from other Chromium browsers.
- Private Browsing Mode:
-
Advertising and Revenue Models:
- Brave's Approach:
- Brave disrupts the traditional advertising model by blocking ads by default and introducing its own ad platform.
- Users can opt into Brave's reward system, earning Basic Attention Tokens (BATs) by viewing privacy-respecting ads.
- BATs can be used to support websites or contributors and converted into actual currency.
- Firefox's Approach:
- Firefox blocks many trackers, cryptominers, and fingerprinting trackers but does not block display ads by default.
- Users can install extensions to block display ads if desired.
- Brave's Approach:
-
Utility:
- Page Loading Speed:
- Brave tends to load pages faster due to its default ad-blocking approach.
- Resource Usage:
- Brave is heavier on RAM usage than Firefox, which allows users to customize add-ons and extensions for a more personalized experience.
- In-Browser Features:
- Firefox provides features like a powerful screenshot tool, accessibility features, and integration with Pocket.
- Brave supports extensions from the Chrome web store and offers unique features like the Brave Rewards program and built-in torrent downloading.
- Page Loading Speed:
-
Portability:
- Syncing Across Devices:
- Both Firefox and Brave offer syncing of passwords, extensions, form data, and preferences across devices.
- Firefox encrypts synced data and provides additional features like Firefox Monitor for data breach alerts.
- Brave recently introduced syncing capabilities, including Basic Attention Tokens.
- Syncing Across Devices:
-
Overall Assessment:
- Privacy and Security:
- Both browsers offer a high level of privacy and security by default.
- Brave's Appeal:
- Brave, with its unique advertising replacement model, may appeal to cryptocurrency users.
- Simplicity:
- Firefox is presented as a simpler solution that may be more suitable for the majority of internet users.
- Privacy and Security:
In conclusion, the article emphasizes that both Firefox and Brave browsers provide robust privacy and security features. The choice between them may depend on user preferences regarding ad blocking, revenue models, and the level of simplicity desired in a browser. The comparisons were conducted with default settings, considering Firefox version 81 and Brave version 1.14.81.