Which Investments to Keep Out of Your Taxable Account (2024)

A few years ago, Vanguard target-date funds’ sizable capital gains distribution led to a nasty tax surprise for investors who had been holding the funds in taxable accounts. In response, the firm agreed to pay more than $6 million to settle an investigation led by Massachusetts Commonwealth Secretary William Galvin.

The incident illustrated a broader point: Some investments are simply a poor fit for investors’ taxable accounts. While it can be hard to see one-off distributions like the Vanguard funds’ in advance, it also happens that target-date funds are structurally ill-suited for taxable accounts. That’s the case for a host of other investment types as well, from REITs to junk bonds to high-dividend stocks and actively managed funds. That’s not to say that investors shouldn’t own them, but rather that they should take pains to house them inside of their tax-sheltered accounts, where income and capital gains distributions won’t result in a tax bill.

Here are some of the key categories to keep out of your taxable accounts.

  1. Taxable bonds and bond funds
  2. Multi-asset funds
  3. Actively managed equity funds
  4. High-dividend-paying equities and dividend-focused funds
  5. REITs and REIT funds
  6. Commodities futures funds
  7. Convertibles (and funds that own them)
  8. Alternatives funds

Taxable Bonds and Bond Funds

Generally speaking, bonds will tend to be less tax-efficient than stocks. That’s because most of the return that bond investors earn is income, and that income is taxed at your ordinary income tax rate, which is higher than the capital gains and dividend tax rates that apply to the gains from most stock holdings. The median taxable-bond fund in Morningstar’s database has a tax-cost ratio of 1.13% over the past 10 years, representing a 67% cut of the median fund’s modest 1.69% return over that time frame. The median 10-year tax-cost ratio for all U.S. stock funds was higher—1.78%—but it represents just 21% of the median fund’s 8.58% gain over that period. Moreover, a number of stock funds, especially broad-market index funds and exchange-traded funds, had tax-cost ratios of less than 0.50%.

Certain bond holdings can be a particularly bad idea for taxable accounts. High-yield bond funds, because they tend to generate (relatively) large amounts of current income, are best avoided in taxable accounts. Ditto for funds that hold Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities, because you’re taxed not just on these bonds’ yields but also on the principal adjustment you receive to account for inflation. (If you want to give your taxable portfolio a measure of inflation protection, consider I Bonds, which enjoy more favorable tax treatment than TIPS.)

But what if you’re using your taxable accounts to save for shorter-term nonretirement goals? From a practical standpoint, that’s what many of us do. If you need to hold bonds in your taxable accounts and you’re in a higher tax bracket—say, 24% or above—check to see whether municipal bonds would be a better bet on an aftertax basis. Whereas any interest you earn from a conventional bond fund is taxed at your own income tax rate, you won’t have to pay federal income tax on a municipal-bond fund’s payout; you may also be able to skirt state income tax by buying a muni fund dedicated to your state’s bonds. For very short-term assets, you can also find municipal money market funds.

Multi-Asset Funds

Multi-asset funds like target-date funds and balanced funds will also tend to be a poor fit for taxable accounts and are much better off housed in a tax-sheltered account like an IRA or 401(k). That’s because they typically hold taxable bonds (see above). Moreover, their asset allocations either stay the same, as is the case with static-allocation funds like balanced funds, or they get more conservative over time, as happens with target-date funds. That can necessitate the sale of appreciated assets like stocks, which in turn can sock investors with capital gains taxes.

It’s true that some multi-asset funds have been quite tax-efficient, in part because categories like target-date funds have enjoyed robust asset inflows. That has given these funds the opportunity to rebalance by directing the new assets to whichever asset class needed topping up. Indeed, the median allocation fund in Morningstar’s database has a 10-year tax-cost ratio of 1.37%, representing 26% of the median fund’s 10-year annualized return—not too much worse than what stock funds have ceded to taxes. Yet that need to sell for rebalancing purposes could work against these funds at some point in the future. Investors in search of a balanced holding in their taxable accounts might consider Vanguard Tax-Managed Balanced VTMFX, which is low-cost and has managed to be exceedingly tax-efficient. Its 10-year tax-cost ratio of 0.47% is just 6% of its 7.27% 10-year annualized return.

Actively Managed Equity Funds

I used to equivocate about whether to hold actively managed funds in taxable accounts. But I’ve seen enough, and the answer is: Don’t do it. Yes, some actively managed equity funds have managed to keep their tax bills low, either because their managers employ low-turnover approaches or they’ve been receiving big shareholder inflows. Both of these factors tend to limit big capital gains payouts. But whether they can continue to do so is an open question. And some active funds have been absolutely awful from a tax standpoint, dishing out large capital gains year after year.

The fact that the stock market has enjoyed a steady upward march for most of the past 15 years has contributed to funds’ tax inefficiency because fund managers have more gains in their portfolios than losses. Manager changes can be a catalyst for big capital gains distributions: As the new guard tosses out older holdings, it realizes taxable gains in the process. Investors’ ongoing preference for index funds and ETFs over actively managed funds has been an even more widespread factor, forcing managers into selling appreciated winners to meet shareholder redemptions. That has led some funds to be serial distributors of large capital gains distributions and has caused tax headaches for the investors who have stuck around. Of course, those distributions increase shareholders’ cost basis, assuming they’re reinvested, but most investors would prefer to realize capital gains on their own schedules, ideally later rather than sooner. Meanwhile, broad-market index mutual funds and especially ETFs have been much more tax-efficient.

High-Dividend-Paying Equities, Dividend-Focused Funds

Investors love their dividends, and they may become especially attached to them if stocks continue to be volatile. And while dividend payers enjoy relatively favorable tax treatment currently, such stocks and funds are arguably a better fit for tax-sheltered rather than taxable accounts.

The key reason is control. Dividend income, like bond income, isn't discretionary. Whereas stock investors can delay the receipt of capital gains simply by hanging on to the stock, investors in dividend-paying stocks get a payout whether they like it or not. That makes dividend payers, regardless of tax treatment, less attractive than nondividend payers from a tax standpoint.

REITs and REIT Funds

Real estate investment trusts are a poor fit for taxable accounts for the reason that I just mentioned. Their income tends to be high and often composes a big share of the returns that investors earn from them, as REITs must pay out a minimum of 90% of their taxable income in dividends each year. Moreover, their dividends typically count as nonqualified, meaning that they’re taxed at higher ordinary income tax rates versus the lower tax rates that apply to qualified dividends.

Commodities Futures Funds

Commodities-tracking funds typically use futures to obtain exposure to the commodities market, and futures’ tax efficiency is poor. Sixty percent of their gains are taxed at the long-term capital gains rate, and the remaining 40% is taxed at the much higher short-term capital gains rate. (For comparison’s sake, the long-term capital gains rate for the highest-income investors is 20% versus 37% for short-term capital gains.)

Convertibles (and Funds That Own Them)

Gains on convertible bonds are generally taxed at ordinary income tax rates, making them ill-suited to investors’ taxable accounts. The median convertible fund in Morningstar’s database has a 10-year tax-cost ratio of 1.85%, representing a 28% bite out of the total return over that time period.

Alternatives Funds

The alternatives group is a broad basket encompassing a lot of different strategies. While tax efficiency hasn’t been poor across the board, some of these funds have been quite tax-inefficient, especially when you consider their low return profile. The category’s median 10-year tax-cost ratio of 1.01% represents 44% of the median return over that time period.

This version of this article previously appeared on July 5, 2023.

The author or authors do not own shares in any securities mentioned in this article.Find out about Morningstar’s editorial policies.

Which Investments to Keep Out of Your Taxable Account (2024)

FAQs

Which Investments to Keep Out of Your Taxable Account? ›

Stocks held for at least a year (and preferably longer) to avoid short-term capital gains. Index and exchange-traded funds, which typically have low turnover. Municipal bonds and Series I bonds, which are not taxed by the federal government. Tax-managed funds that focus on keeping your tax liability low.

Should I hold treasuries in a taxable account? ›

Treasury bonds are exempt from state taxes, making them tax-inefficient for federal taxes, but they may be desirable taxable investments for investors who pay high state taxes but low federal taxes.

Should you hold ETFs in a taxable account? ›

ETFs can be more tax efficient compared to traditional mutual funds. Generally, holding an ETF in a taxable account will generate less tax liabilities than if you held a similarly structured mutual fund in the same account. From the perspective of the IRS, the tax treatment of ETFs and mutual funds are the same.

What investments are not subject to taxation? ›

Municipal bonds are generally free of federal tax because the interest from bonds issued by a state, municipality, or other local entity is exempt from federal taxation.

Is a Roth IRA a taxable account? ›

Roth IRAs allow you to pay taxes on money going into your account and then all future withdrawals are tax-free. Roth IRA contributions aren't taxed because the contributions you make to them are usually made with after-tax money, and you can't deduct them.

Should I hold REITs in taxable accounts? ›

When an investor sells REIT shares, any appreciation is also subject to capital gains taxes. Holding REITs in tax-advantaged accounts like individual retirement accounts can defer or eliminate taxes on distributions, potentially making them more tax-efficient for some investors.

Should I put my money in Treasuries? ›

Why should I buy a Treasury security? Treasury securities are considered a safe and secure investment option because the full faith and credit of the U.S. government guarantees that interest and principal payments will be paid on time.

Which treasury bonds are tax-free? ›

Interest from Treasuries is generally taxable at the federal level, but not at the state level. Interest from munis is generally exempt from federal taxes, and if you live in the state where the bond was issued, the interest may also be exempt from state taxes.

What is the best investment for a tax-free savings account? ›

Bonds in a TFSA

Bonds pay out periodic payments throughout the term. And, when compared to stocks, bonds may generally be considered safer investments. Look for a bond with a term that matches the timeframe of your goals.

How do you avoid tax on treasury bonds? ›

Use the Education Exclusion

You can skip paying taxes on interest earned with Series EE and Series I savings bonds if you're using the money to pay for qualified higher education costs. That includes expenses you pay for yourself, your spouse or a qualified dependent.

Should you hold bonds in a taxable account? ›

Certain bond holdings can be a particularly bad idea for taxable accounts. High-yield bond funds, because they tend to generate (relatively) large amounts of current income, are best avoided in taxable accounts.

Which fund is most tax-efficient? ›

Index mutual funds & ETFs

Index funds—whether mutual funds or ETFs (exchange-traded funds)—are naturally tax-efficient for a couple of reasons: Because index funds simply replicate the holdings of an index, they don't trade in and out of securities as often as an active fund would.

Should you buy tips in a taxable account? ›

Investors hoping to avoid possible tax liability of “Phantom Income,” should consider purchasing TIPS in a tax-deferred account. Investors are urged to consult with their own tax advisors with regard to their specific situation prior to making any investment decisions with tax consequences.

What is the best investment for a tax free savings account? ›

Bonds in a TFSA

Bonds pay out periodic payments throughout the term. And, when compared to stocks, bonds may generally be considered safer investments. Look for a bond with a term that matches the timeframe of your goals.

Is it okay to have dividend stocks in a taxable account? ›

Incorporating dividend stocks into taxable accounts is often a prudent strategy for investors who want to cultivate a reliable income stream and tax-efficient returns.

What is the best investment for tax deduction? ›

Tax-Efficient Investments

Among stock funds, for example, tax-managed funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) tend to be more tax-efficient because they trigger fewer capital gains. Actively managed funds tend to buy and sell securities often and can generate more capital gains distributions and more taxes.

Top Articles
Finance
A goal of data mining includes which of the following?To confirm that data exitsTo explain some observed event or conditionNone of theseTo analyse data expected relationshipsTo create a new data warehouse
Cranes For Sale in United States| IronPlanet
Average Jonas Wife
Frederick County Craigslist
Ret Paladin Phase 2 Bis Wotlk
Craigslist Parsippany Nj Rooms For Rent
Comcast Xfinity Outage in Kipton, Ohio
Toyota gebraucht kaufen in tacoma_ - AutoScout24
Emmalangevin Fanhouse Leak
Osrs But Damage
Deshret's Spirit
Jessica Renee Johnson Update 2023
Purple Crip Strain Leafly
Craigslist Cars Nwi
2021 Lexus IS for sale - Richardson, TX - craigslist
Slope Tyrones Unblocked Games
History of Osceola County
Khiara Keating: Manchester City and England goalkeeper convinced WSL silverware is on the horizon
Missed Connections Dayton Ohio
Lcwc 911 Live Incident List Live Status
Race Karts For Sale Near Me
Full Standard Operating Guideline Manual | Springfield, MO
Katie Sigmond Hot Pics
Free Personals Like Craigslist Nh
Anonib Oviedo
Rgb Bird Flop
Sacramento Craigslist Cars And Trucks - By Owner
Bfri Forum
Gideon Nicole Riddley Read Online Free
Haley Gifts :: Stardew Valley
John F Slater Funeral Home Brentwood
Acadis Portal Missouri
Tirage Rapid Georgia
The Transformation Of Vanessa Ray From Childhood To Blue Bloods - Looper
Ksu Sturgis Library
Pepsi Collaboration
Miracle Shoes Ff6
Emily Tosta Butt
Craigslist Odessa Midland Texas
Sarahbustani Boobs
Courses In Touch
Craigslist Com St Cloud Mn
Iupui Course Search
Interminable Rooms
3500 Orchard Place
Gonzalo Lira Net Worth
Abigail Cordova Murder
Game Like Tales Of Androgyny
Nfhs Network On Direct Tv
Ocean County Mugshots
Anthony Weary Obituary Erie Pa
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 6507

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.