What are the most effective methods for valuing distressed properties? (2024)

One of the most common and straightforward methods for valuing distressed properties is to compare them with similar properties that have sold recently in the same area. This method is also known as the market approach or the sales comparison approach. To use this method, you need to find at least three comparable properties that have similar features, size, location, and condition as the distressed property. Then, you need to adjust the sales prices of the comparable properties to account for any differences or improvements that affect their value. For example, if the distressed property has a damaged roof, you need to deduct the cost of repairing it from the sales price of a comparable property that has a good roof. The average of the adjusted sales prices of the comparable properties is the estimated value of the distressed property.

Another method for valuing distressed properties is to estimate their potential income and apply a capitalization rate or a multiplier to it. This method is also known as the income approach or the income capitalization approach. To use this method, you need to estimate the net operating income (NOI) of the distressed property, which is the gross income minus the operating expenses. Then, you need to divide the NOI by the capitalization rate or multiply it by the multiplier, which are both derived from the market rates of return for similar properties. The capitalization rate is the percentage of income that an investor expects to earn from a property, while the multiplier is the inverse of the capitalization rate. For example, if the NOI of a distressed property is $10,000 and the capitalization rate is 10%, the estimated value of the property is $100,000. Alternatively, if the multiplier is 10, the estimated value of the property is also $100,000.

A third method for valuing distressed properties is to estimate their replacement or reproduction cost and subtract their depreciation. This method is also known as the cost approach or the summation approach. To use this method, you need to estimate how much it would cost to build a new property that is identical or similar to the distressed property, including the land, labor, materials, and fees. This is the replacement or reproduction cost of the property. Then, you need to estimate how much the property has lost in value due to physical deterioration, functional obsolescence, or economic obsolescence. This is the depreciation of the property. The difference between the replacement or reproduction cost and the depreciation is the estimated value of the property.

In some cases, you may need to use a combination of the methods described above to value distressed properties. This is especially true if there are not enough comparable sales, if the income potential is uncertain, or if the cost of construction is volatile. For example, you may use the comparable sales method to estimate the value of the land and the cost approach to estimate the value of the improvements. Or, you may use the income approach to estimate the value of the property as a rental and the comparable sales method to estimate the value of the property as a sale. By using hybrid methods, you can capture different aspects of the value of distressed properties and cross-check your results.

Valuing distressed properties can be made easier and more accurate by utilizing software tools. PropStream, for example, is a platform that enables access to and filtering of data on millions of properties across the US, including foreclosures, auctions, and pre-foreclosures. DealMachine is an app that allows you to contact distressed property owners, analyze deals, estimate values, and track progress. BiggerPockets is a community and resource for real estate investors with tools and calculators to find and analyze deals, estimate values, and evaluate strategies. With the help of these software tools, you can make your valuation process more efficient and reliable.

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Property Management

+ Follow

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.