Selling on Amazon vs an Ecommerce Website: Pros & Cons (2024)

Every new seller making the transition to Amazon’s marketplace automatically accesses a global audience. In this article, we discuss a few trends in Amazon eCommerce and eCommerce marketplaces in general. Then, we turn to the advantages and disadvantages of selling on Amazon. While it’s not a zero-sum game, you need to know what starting a relationship with Amazon means for your business.

Your Amazon/eCommerce Strategy

But these are complex questions, littered with nuances depending on your company’s circ*mstances and future aims. That’s why in this article, we’ll be looking at the pros and cons of selling on Amazon vs your eCommerce website.

Here’s what we’ll be covering:

  • Amazon and Global Ecommerce Trends
  • Advantages of Selling on an Ecommerce Site
  • Advantages of Selling on Amazon
  • Amazon’s Limitations and the Role of Your Ecommerce Store
  • Should I Sell on Amazon?

Amazon and Global Ecommerce Trends

Both Amazon and eCommerce are growing at a rapid pace. In 2019, marketplaces contributed to 52% of global online retail sales. After all, online marketplaces account for the majority of global sales nowadays. In Europe, where many already have access to the internet, eCommerce grew by 14.2% in 2019. The global concerns around COVID-19 also accelerated the focus around eCommerce, allowing Amazon to grow 63.3% during the crisis thus far.

Amazon’s strategy is foundational to its success. Manypieces contribute to this puzzle: customer loyalty, owning buyers with the highest search intent, then selling their customer data. The firm focuses on continuously enhancing customer experience and lowering prices along the way.

Under Amazon, customer service wins, and who is prepared to fight them? Wholesalers and retailers have a lot to consider as Amazon remains omnipotent in today’s market. Most important, businesses also need to make strategic decisions around Amazon and marketplaces in general. After all, Amazon has many pros and cons. Before jumping into the specifics of why you should sell on Amazon, let’s examine Amazon’s strategic advantage.

Whether you’re a brand, distributor, retailer or manufacturer, you cannot ignore Amazon as a sales channel.

Advantages of Selling on an eCommerce site

  1. Full Control

    With an eCommerce site, you have full control of every step of the customer purchasing journey. You choose how customers discover, interact, purchase and receive deliveries from your business.

  2. Tell your unique brand story

    You have full control of your brand identity and messaging at all times—which also means it can be tailored and amended to match your strategic priorities.

  3. Use Customer Data for Personalisation

    Selling on an eCommerce site yields valuable customer information that helps your business. This data boosts your personalisation with email marketing campaigns, targeted discounts, and improved shopping experiences.

Advantages of selling on Amazon

Many benefits come from selling on Amazon: trust, customers, and fulfilment. Let’s learn more about the accounts’ particular benefits.

  1. Access Purchase-Ready Customers

    The number one benefit of selling through Amazon is instant access to purchase-ready customers. Amazon shoppers often skip the awareness phase and already know what product they want. This access to customers with high buying intent is one of Amazon’s competitive advantages and good for new businesses looking to grow their audience.

  2. Amazon’s Reputation

    Customers buy from Amazon because of its reputation for an excellent customer experience. By selling through Amazon, your business benefits from Amazon’s brand.

  3. It’s easy to use

    From a practical standpoint, it’s easy to start selling on Amazon—taking 24 hours if you’re prepared.

  4. Fulfilment by Amazon (FBA)

    When you sell with Amazon FBA, you store your products in Amazon’s fulfilment centres and let them pick, pack, ship, and provide customer service for your products. With Amazon handling logistics, you save valuable time and resources.

Amazon’s limitations/Disadvantages

Amazon’s strengths are also its weaknesses. Yes, millions of loyal customers shop on Amazon. But they love Amazon’s marketplace—not you.

  1. Amazon’s Customer Loyalty

    While customers buy your products, they are loyal to Amazon, which owns the marketplace and restricts how you can brand your online store. You can display your name and logo as well as a few images but cannot link to your website and social media.

  2. No Data Access for Amazon Sellers

    Amazon restricts your access to crucial customer information. Without access to your customers’ behaviour on Amazon, you lose the opportunity to personalise your experience.

  3. Amazon limits your brand

    In terms of brand-building, Amazon is a bad option. In most cases, a shopper will type ‘mobile phone case’ into the search bar on Amazon’s homepage. They might filter by price, average customer rating, or get distracted by one of the sponsored products at the top of the page. As a result, Amazon removes your brand from the buying process. Instead, customers focus on product reviews, price and popularity on the Amazon marketplace. Your business, in the end, competes with thousands of other sellers, without using your unique brand story.

  4. Amazon FBA takes control of your business

    Although FBA has advantages, you also lose control over your inventory. For example, Amazon might move products between warehouses, rendering them unsellable while in transit. By letting Amazon manage your inventory, you also lose control of your logistics chain. In delivering your products, you lose the chance to interact with your customers during the crucial last mile. Last, Amazon charges an FBA fee, which could impact your business’s profit.

  5. Amazon could take advantage of your success

    If Amazon notices the success of your product, they might replicate your product and outcompete you.

The bottom line—should I sell on Amazon?

There are both advantages and disadvantages of selling on Amazon. The big drawback is that you lose control of your brand while selling on Amazon. But, your company’s channel strategy can benefit from selling on Amazon. In the end, you’ll need to consider your company’s ambitions, market share and size. You can start weighing the pros and cons with Vaimo, an experienced partner to global brands in ecommerce, online marketplaces, and much more.

Would you like more advice on this topic?

As an enthusiast and expert in eCommerce, particularly in the context of Amazon, I bring a wealth of knowledge and firsthand experience to the table. Over the years, I've closely followed the dynamic landscape of online marketplaces and the intricacies of selling on platforms like Amazon. My insights are rooted in both theoretical understanding and practical applications, making me well-equipped to delve into the various facets of Amazon's role in the eCommerce ecosystem.

Now, let's dissect the key concepts and information presented in the provided article:

Amazon and Global Ecommerce Trends

1. Market Growth:

  • In 2019, marketplaces contributed to 52% of global online retail sales.
  • eCommerce in Europe grew by 14.2% in 2019.
  • The global concerns around COVID-19 accelerated eCommerce, leading to a 63.3% growth for Amazon during the crisis.

2. Amazon's Strategy:

  • Amazon's success is attributed to a multifaceted strategy, including customer loyalty, owning high search intent, and selling customer data.
  • The focus on enhancing customer experience and lowering prices contributes to Amazon's strategic advantage.

Advantages of Selling on an eCommerce Site

1. Full Control:

  • With an eCommerce site, businesses have complete control over the customer purchasing journey.
  • Full autonomy in shaping brand identity and messaging to align with strategic priorities.

2. Customer Data Utilization:

  • Selling on an eCommerce site provides valuable customer information for personalization in marketing campaigns, discounts, and shopping experiences.

Advantages of Selling on Amazon

1. Access to Purchase-Ready Customers:

  • Instant access to customers with high buying intent is a key advantage of selling on Amazon.
  • Shoppers often skip the awareness phase and already know what product they want.

2. Amazon's Reputation:

  • Businesses benefit from Amazon's brand reputation, leading to trust and credibility among customers.

3. Ease of Use and Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA):

  • Practical ease of starting to sell on Amazon within 24 hours.
  • FBA allows businesses to store products in Amazon's fulfillment centers, saving time and resources.

Amazon's Limitations/Disadvantages

1. Customer Loyalty:

  • Customers may buy products but remain loyal to Amazon, limiting the establishment of brand loyalty for individual sellers.

2. Data Access Restrictions:

  • Limited access to crucial customer information restricts the ability to personalize the customer experience.

3. Brand Limitations:

  • Amazon's focus on product reviews, price, and popularity overshadows individual brand stories, making it challenging for sellers to differentiate.

4. FBA Challenges:

  • While FBA has advantages, it comes with challenges such as loss of control over inventory and potential fees impacting profit margins.

5. Potential Competition from Amazon:

  • If a product achieves success on Amazon, there's a risk of Amazon replicating it and competing directly with the original seller.

Should I Sell on Amazon?

1. Consideration Factors:

  • Businesses need to weigh the pros and cons based on their ambitions, market share, and size.
  • The decision should align with the overall channel strategy and business goals.

2. Consultation:

  • Consider seeking advice from experienced partners in eCommerce, such as Vaimo, to navigate the complexities of online marketplaces.

In conclusion, the decision to sell on Amazon involves a careful consideration of the advantages and disadvantages outlined in the article, taking into account the unique circ*mstances and goals of each business.

Selling on Amazon vs an Ecommerce Website: Pros & Cons (2024)

FAQs

Is it better to sell on Amazon or on your own website? ›

Choosing to sell on Amazon versus your own website can also offer your brand protection. With Amazon Brand Registry, your company can get protection against knock-off versions of your products. You can also report copy-cat sellers. This program helps your business protect its brand and increase its sales.

What are the drawbacks of selling on Amazon? ›

8 biggest cons of selling on Amazon
  • High competition. ...
  • High selling fees. ...
  • Complex order management. ...
  • Lack of control and ownership. ...
  • No insight into customer data. ...
  • Risk of scams. ...
  • Limited warehouse space. ...
  • No control over customer care and satisfaction.
Dec 19, 2023

Is it worth selling on Amazon as an individual? ›

Amazon sellers are profiting much sooner compared to a typical small brick-and-mortar business. While it may take the latter 2+ years to turn a profit, 22% of Amazon sellers reported it took less than 3 months to turn a profit, and 58% are profitable within their first year.

Is selling on Amazon considered ecommerce? ›

Other options include starting out on an established ecommerce website like Amazon.com, or selling through social media sites like Facebook, Instagram, or Pinterest.

Do you actually make money as an Amazon seller? ›

Selling on Amazon can be a very lucrative business for many — more than the average side hustle. 19% of Amazon sellers surpass $10,000 in average monthly sales. 30% of Amazon sellers report sales above $5,000/month. 31% of sellers make under $500/month in sales when first starting out.

What should I not do when selling on Amazon? ›

With that in mind, let us take a look at 10 Amazon seller mistakes that you should avoid at all costs.
  1. Picking an over-saturated niche.
  2. Not paying attention to customer service.
  3. Lack of effort in preparing Amazon product listing.
  4. Overly-priced shipping options.
  5. Failure to fulfil orders on time.

What are three disadvantages of Amazon? ›

Top 10 Cons & Disadvantages of Amazon
  • Impact on Small Businesses.
  • Worker Exploitation.
  • Environmental Impact.
  • Market Monopoly.
  • Data Privacy Concerns.
  • Impact on Innovation.
  • Dependence on Amazon Services.
  • Quality Control Issues.
Apr 26, 2024

Is it possible to lose money selling on Amazon? ›

For Amazon sellers, offering an item that's similar to something already found on Amazon.com, Alibaba.com, or some other website is a sure-fire path to financial loss. And, spending money on advertising or cutting prices to try to and differentiate that sort of product is a waste of time.

Is it realistic to sell on Amazon? ›

More sales

We can see that Amazon is the number 1 place to go for most shoppers. By listing their products on Amazon, every retailer automatically gains credibility and trust. That's because some users are more likely to buy a product from Amazon rather than from a shop they never heard of.

Why is selling on Amazon so complicated? ›

As an Amazon seller, you'll need a strong understanding of the platform and its algorithms and a well-executed marketing strategy. With millions of products on Amazon, competition can be fierce, making it all the more difficult to stand out.

What does the average Amazon seller make? ›

Most sellers make at least $1,000 per month in sales, and some super-sellers are making more than $100,000 each month! This is what you should know about selling on Amazon. According to statistics, 50% of store owners on Amazon make $1,000 – $25,000/month, which could mean $12,000 to $300,000 in annual sales.

What percentage does Amazon take from sellers? ›

What percentage does Amazon take from sellers? As of my last knowledge update in January 2022, Amazon's referral fees vary depending on the category of the product being sold. Typically, referral fees range from 6% to 45% of the item's sale price, with most categories falling in the 8% to 15% range.

Which is better, Amazon or Shopify? ›

Shopify is ideal for e-commerce entrepreneurs looking to develop their own brand through its website builder. On the other hand, Amazon is suitable for those who want to take advantage of the thriving Amazon marketplace.

What are the three types of e-commerce? ›

There are three main types of e-commerce: business-to-business (websites such as Shopify), business-to-consumer (websites such as Amazon), and consumer-to-consumer (websites such as eBay).

What does FBA mean on Amazon? ›

What is Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA)? Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is a program that lets you outsource order fulfillment to Amazon and offer customers free, two-day shipping through Prime.

Is there a downside to selling online? ›

Selling online offers numerous advantages, including a global reach, lower overhead costs, and 24/7 availability. However, it also comes with its own set of challenges, such as intense competition, limited personal interaction, security risks, and logistical complexities.

Do you have to pay Amazon to sell on their website? ›

Whatever you choose to sell, you'll have to pay Amazon for the ability to list products on its site. You can do this with either an Individual Seller Account or a Professional Seller Account. The Individual Account costs you $0.99 per item sold, and the Professional Sellers Account is $39.99 per month.

Is it beneficial to sell on Amazon? ›

Selling on Amazon does give you automatic credibility as a seller. Buyers are quick to trust that you're reputable when they see you have a well-made Amazon product page. Yes, you do need to pay referral fees for items you sell but it could turn out being worth the traffic it brings you.

Should I use my personal account to sell on Amazon? ›

An individual account can be cost-effective if you have small inventory or expect to sell only a few items per month. Instead of paying a monthly subscription fee, you only pay a fee when an item sells.

Top Articles
How-to Choose an Interior Paint Sheen | Behr
HELP! what happens if I fail?
Pinellas County Jail Mugshots 2023
Practical Magic 123Movies
Displays settings on Mac
Stolen Touches Neva Altaj Read Online Free
Sunday World Northern Ireland
4156303136
Why Is Stemtox So Expensive
Dexter Gomovies
Price Of Gas At Sam's
Samantha Lyne Wikipedia
Fdny Business
Transfer and Pay with Wells Fargo Online®
Niche Crime Rate
Der Megatrend Urbanisierung
The Menu Showtimes Near Regal Edwards Ontario Mountain Village
Gopher Hockey Forum
The Many Faces of the Craigslist Killer
Redfin Skagit County
Troy Gamefarm Prices
Harrison County Wv Arrests This Week
Wku Lpn To Rn
Lilpeachbutt69 Stephanie Chavez
Darktide Terrifying Barrage
What Is Opm1 Treas 310 Deposit
Prévisions météo Paris à 15 jours - 1er site météo pour l'île-de-France
Boondock Eddie's Menu
What Happened To Father Anthony Mary Ewtn
M3Gan Showtimes Near Cinemark North Hills And Xd
Powerspec G512
Ewwwww Gif
Muziq Najm
دانلود سریال خاندان اژدها دیجی موویز
Koninklijk Theater Tuschinski
Spn-523318
Publictributes
968 woorden beginnen met kruis
Great Clips Virginia Center Commons
Immobiliare di Felice| Appartamento | Appartamento in vendita Porto San
Actor and beloved baritone James Earl Jones dies at 93
Anderson Tribute Center Hood River
Pulaski County Ky Mugshots Busted Newspaper
Meet Robert Oppenheimer, the destroyer of worlds
Gander Mountain Mastercard Login
Walmart Listings Near Me
Dolce Luna Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Edict Of Force Poe
Black Adam Showtimes Near Cinemark Texarkana 14
2121 Gateway Point
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Manual Maggio

Last Updated:

Views: 5676

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Manual Maggio

Birthday: 1998-01-20

Address: 359 Kelvin Stream, Lake Eldonview, MT 33517-1242

Phone: +577037762465

Job: Product Hospitality Supervisor

Hobby: Gardening, Web surfing, Video gaming, Amateur radio, Flag Football, Reading, Table tennis

Introduction: My name is Manual Maggio, I am a thankful, tender, adventurous, delightful, fantastic, proud, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.