NZ vs OZ: What's better? - Good Returns (2024)

A comparison of residential house price yields across the Tasman has turned up interesting results, with both New Zealand and Australia showing they're good places to invest, but for different reasons.

Wednesday, July 2nd 2008, 12:00PM

by The Landlord

Crockers’ latest research data tracked median selling prices for homes in key cities of Australia and New Zealand between 2004 and 2008. Then they looked at median three-bedroom rentals to come up with estimated rental yield trends.

While they found rental yields have fallen by almost 21% in Auckland, they have been rising dramatically in Australia. Sydney experienced an increase of around 30% and Melbourne 16%. However, they still remain lower than in Auckland, where properties are now returning yields of 5.02%. All of the New Zealand cities offer yields of between 5% and 6%, whereas Australian cities are offering between 3% and 5% – except for Darwin. Darwin shows the top rate for all Australian cities with an estimated 6.07% yield.

However, yields must be balanced by a look at capital gains made during this period and these present another picture. Over the past four years, Sydney prices have remained almost static – in stark contrast to Auckland’s prices – which virtually doubled, gaining 44% in an uninterrupted climb.

Melbourne fared slightly better than Sydney with 15% growth. Greatest growth in Australia came from the boom time economies of Queensland and Western Australia in particular. In Darwin and Perth property prices almost doubled between 2004 and 2008. Brisbane showed a 50% increase and Canberra 28%.

Wellington, like Auckland, experienced consistently rising prices resulting in a 56% increase over the same period. Of the next cities, Christchurch, Adelaide and Hobart all show almost identical rising trends, as does Dunedin.

Crockers’ Karen Coleman says this research indicates the New Zealand property market overall looks pretty good as a place to invest.

“While Australian yields are low, you’ve got to remember they also have lower interest rates and you’ve got to factor that in. But the New Zealand property market continues to be a good investment option long term."

Commenting is closed

• Nikko explains its new name
• A large portion of investors don’t know what they’re taxed, survey says
• Raining PIE funds

MORE NEWS BITES»

• It’s time we indexed health insurance
  “@KeepThingsSimple At the time of purchase of the medical contract, it is fit for purpose. There are a couple if medical insurers...”
  1 day ago by Backstage
• AMP moves ANZ money to BlackRock
  “Another distributor for Blackrock...”
  1 day ago by Pragmatic
• The messed up world of income protection structures
  “I’ve often thought it must be a scary place in that head of yours JP. But as always, you have illustrated some very pertinent...”
  2 days ago by John Milner
• It’s time we indexed health insurance
  “@Backstage, I don't think that the IBM analogy is apt. The sale of a computer involves a single transaction between the...”
  4 days ago by KeepThingsSimple
• It’s time we indexed health insurance
  “I think it could be time to focus forward and not get tangled up on old tolls that were ok at the time. The underlying assumption...”
  5 days ago by Backstage

Mortgage Rates Newsletter

Video [VIDEO] Don’t expect a buyers’ market immediately

• Tuesday, August 20th, 1:57PM
  From hunted to hunters
• Monday, August 5th, 10:11AM
  First home buyers fade, investors rise
• Sunday, June 23rd, 6:54AM
  Alternative to first home grant
• Thursday, June 20th, 10:23AM
  Growing number of property investment dollars moving across the ditch
• Thursday, June 20th, 6:43AM
  Market could be near a tipping point
• Wednesday, June 5th, 10:41AM
  Options for buyers locked out of scrapped first home loan grant
• Monday, May 27th, 10:46AM
  First home buyers making hay, investors MIA
• Wednesday, May 15th, 1:57PM
  Sticky market for investors – first home buyers in control

MORE NEWS»

• It’s time we indexed health insurance
• ESG KiwiSaver outperforms non-ESG on some profiles over five years
• The messed up world of income protection structures
• AMP moves ANZ money to BlackRock
• Chubb boss to retire

Full Rates Table | Compare Rates