NordVPN vs Proton VPN: 1 Clear Winner (September 2024) (2024)

NordVPN and Proton VPN are both popular VPN services, but the latest test results for 2024 show there is one very clear winner, especially in terms of speeds, security features, and overall value.

NordVPN and Proton VPN are well-respected names in the VPN industry and privacy community at large. While NordVPN has been around longer and is one of the most popular VPNs in the industry, Proton VPN is also making a name for itself and growing. So who comes out on top in this Proton VPN vs NordVPN comparison?

We’ll let the test results show you the answer to that question a bit further below. But first, let’s cover the basics of each VPN service:

NordVPN continues to be a leading VPN globally, with an extensive server infrastructure, superior speed, and security, with a range of privacy options that most VPNs can’t match. They consistently outdo other VPNs in terms of functionality, features, and streaming performance.

Proton VPN is also focused on privacy and security but has a smaller set of features, a higher price, and less access to popular streaming sites.Additionally, there have been a few different logging cases involving Proton Mail, the sister company of Proton VPN, logging user IP addresses for government authorities. While Proton VPN is an audited no-log VPN, the fact that their sister company was involved in these different cases may give you pause.

So which one comes out on top in this NordVPN vs Proton VPN comparison? While we like and recommend both of these services, there was a clear winner in almost every category. Here are the areas we’ll examine:

1. Company background and jurisdiction
2. Features
3. Speed tests
4. Streaming and torrenting
5. Security and Encryption
6. Privacy
7. Prices and Refunds
8. Value

We’ll take a deep dive into each of these categories, while also posting the test results below. By naming a winner in each category, we hope to give you a fast way to identify the VPN that is most worth your attention.

Background and jurisdiction: Proton VPN vs NordVPN

Learning something about the background of a company that you are going to trust with your privacy makes sense. While a VPN can prevent others from spying on your online activities, you need to be able to trust the VPN not to spy on you.

Unfortunately, some VPNs have done exactly that, sharing what users thought was private information with various third parties (often law enforcement). For example,PureVPN shared information about a user with the FBI, despite claiming to be a no-logs VPN. To see how PureVPN compares to NordVPN in other ways, check out this NordVPN vs PureVPN article.

Given that, let’s see what we can learn about the companies behind these two VPNs.

NordVPN background and jurisdiction

Website	NordVPN.com
Based in	Panama
Logs	No logs (audited)
Price	$3.09/mo.
Support	24/7 live chat
Refund	30 days
Deal	74% Off Coupon

74% Off NordVPN Coupon >

NordVPN is one of the best-known companies in the VPN industry. It is part of NordSec, a brand that includes NordVPN, and other security products including the secure password manager NordPass, and the encryption/cloud storage toolNordLocker. This company has an excellent background and track record and has also passed multiple third-party audits.

NordVPN is strategically based in Panama, a strong privacy jurisdiction that is not part of any surveillance alliances. The country does not have any mandatory data retention or logging laws.These characteristics make Panama an excellent jurisdiction for privacy-focused services like NordVPN. You can see some of the disadvantages of a VPN based in a bad privacy jurisdiction in our NordVPN vs TorGuard comparison.

Our NordVPN review has more information on the company’s background.

Proton VPN background and jurisdiction

Website	ProtonVPN.com
Based in	Switzerland
Logs	No logs (audited)
Price	$3.59/mo.
Support	Email + Chat
Refund	30 days
Deal	64% Off Coupon

64% OFF Proton VPN Coupon >>

Proton VPN comes to us from the team behind Proton Mail. The parent company of Proton VPN (and ProtonMail) is Proton Technologies, a well-respected company based in Switzerland. Like Panama, Switzerland is a good privacy jurisdiction and is not a party to any international surveillance alliances.

Even before Proton VPN was officially launched in 2017, Proton Mail had built up a strong following in the privacy community. It is one of the leading secure email services. Today, you can combine both Proton Mail and Proton VPN under one subscription.

In the Proton VPN review, we noted how Proton has a history of targeted logging against specific users, based on Swiss court orders. Here are two examples of this that we have covered on RestorePrivacy:

• Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain
• ProtonMail Gives Up Logs on User, Then Scrubs Website of No IP Logging Claims

Both NordVPN and Proton VPN are backed by reputable companies based in privacy-friendly jurisdictions. But we do consider Panama to be a slightly better jurisdiction for privacy than Switzerland. Additionally, Switzerland has been able to pressure Proton Technologies into logging users for law enforcement, while to our knowledge Panama has never tried to pressure any NordSec company to log anything.

NordVPN vs Proton VPN Features

Now we will examine how Proton VPN and NordVPN compare with each other in the features category.

Proton VPN features

Proton VPN’s network currently consists of 6,500+ servers in 112 countries. This is a good-sized network and should be sufficient for your needs.

Unfortunately, you need to be subscribed to the paid Proton VPN plans to use most of those servers. Proton Free subscribers are limited to a small number of free (slower) servers located in three countries. There are also other limitations of the Proton Free plan, such as no streaming, torrenting, or access to Secure Core server access.

The company claims that its network provides high-speed connections for premium users. But in our tests with a paid account, we simply could not find a server that was anywhere near the speeds that NordVPN delivers.

The Proton VPN apps are sharp-looking, and have useful privacy and security features such as a kill switch, auto-reconnection to the network, DNS leak protection, and split tunneling (on some of their apps). All Proton VPN apps are open source. They provide apps for Windows, Mac, Linux, iOS, Android, and various VPN routers.

Here you can see some of the privacy features of the Proton VPNWindows VPN app that we tested:

Double VPN servers are actually two VPN servers connected sequentially. By sending your internet traffic through two servers in this way, it becomes extremely difficult for a hostile entity to associate specific internet traffic with particular users. This is true even if the hostile entity manages to get control of one of the two servers in this configuration.

The Proton VPN Secure Core feature is a type of double VPN feature. Proton Technologies says what makes Secure Core different from other double VPN features is the effort they put into protecting these servers. Proton VPN also offers P2P servers, but they weren’t as fast as NordVPN.

They are installed in high-security data centers to ensure strong physical security. Secure Core servers are wholly owned and provisioned by Proton VPN(what NordVPN and other companies call colocated servers). In addition, Secure Core servers are connected to the Internet using Proton VPN’s own dedicated network using IP addresses that are owned and operated by Proton VPN’s own Local Internet Registry (LIR).

These are all good characteristics for the Secure Core feature to possess. That said, it is unclear to me whether Secure Core provides any significant advantages over the double VPN configurations of services like NordVPN and Surfshark, which also select secure data centers and are in the process of moving to 100% colocated servers (rather than just the subset of all servers that Secure Core includes).

Stealth protocol. This is Proton VPN’s “undetectable” obfuscation feature that disguises VPN traffic to hide it from internet censors and also gets around VPN blocks. The company claims that Stealth is superior to other obfuscated protocols because it was designed from the ground up instead of being a hack on top of an existing protocol. This may be useful if you need a VPN for UAE, where VPNs are often blocked.

VPN Accelerator and Tor-Over-VPN. This feature is built into all Proton VPN apps. It is said to deliver speeds up to 400% faster than you would get without the accelerator, especially when you are using a “less reliable” internet connection. There are also Tor-Over-VPN servers you can use with Proton VPN.

NetShield Ad-blocker. This is a VPN ad-blocking DNS filter that protects your devices from ads, trackers, and malicious software by preventing your devices from connecting to domains where these kinds of things are found. It works much the same as NordVPN’s Threat Protection Lite.

NordVPN features

NordVPN has all the basic featuresthat we covered with Proton VPN, including built-in leak protection and kill switches on all their VPN apps. But NordVPN also offers manyadvanced privacy features. They have apps for everything Proton VPN does and more. They also support options such as Android TV, gaming consoles, and Raspberry Pi.

NordVPN features WireGuard support in the form of a custom VPN protocol called NordLynx. A privacy-first implementation of Wireguard, NordLynx improves WireGuard privacy using a Double NAT system to ensure that user IP addresses never appear on the VPN servers. See our WireGuard VPN guide for details. By default, NordVPN is configured to automatically select the best VPN protocol for any situation. However, you can force it to use NordLynx manually if you wish in Settings:

NordVPN has servers in 111 countries worldwide and their network contains over 6,400 servers. This is slightly more servers and more countries than we see with Proton VPN. And unlike Proton VPN, the entire NordVPN server network is available to all users(no restrictions).

As you’ll see shortly, the NordVPN network is faster than the Proton VPN network, with many of Nord’s servers already upgraded to 10 Gbps data connections. While Proton VPN’s Secure Core servers are colocated (installed and managed) by Proton Technologies, NordVPN is transitioning to colocation for all 6,400+ of their servers.

Another difference between NordVPN and Proton VPN is that NordVPN offers more specialty servers for various use cases:

• P2P servers optimized for torrenting. These fast servers are ideal for torrenting large files.
• Obfuscated servers that conceal VPN traffic as regular HTTPS encryption, like Proton VPN’s Stealth protocol. A great tool if you need a VPN for China or the UAE, where VPNs are blocked. As explained here Proton VPN has been blocked in China since 2019. We have not received any information to the contrary since then.
• Double-VPN servers encrypt VPN traffic over two different locations. Similar to Proton VPN’s Secure Core servers.
• Tor-over-VPN servers add an additional layer of encryption via the Tor network.
• Dedicated IP servers for those applications where you want or need a fixed IP address plus the security of a VPN, dedicated IP servers are the ideal solution.
• Meshnet is a new feature that allows you to create a VPN connection across a private network of trusted NordVPN devices.

See all NordVPN features here >

Here’s the NordVPN Windows client. On the left side of the app, you can see the specialty servers, with an active connection to a Double VPN (United States – Canada) server configuration.

One last NordVPN feature to consider is Threat Protection. This feature is included in NordVPN’s Windows and macOS desktop apps. It blocks ads, trackers, and malware, and can even scan documents you download for malware before you can open them. This turns NordVPN into a powerful VPN ad blocker for all your devices. Threat Protection protects everything, even apps and services that are not connected to the VPN.

Threat Protection Lite provides a similar level of protection to what Proton VPN’s NetShield delivers. Threat Protection Lite is available for most NordVPN apps and browser extensions that do not support the full Threat Protection feature.

Features winner: NordVPN

NordVPN vs Proton VPN speed tests

Given all the work a VPN must do to protect your data, it is only logical that they would slow your VPN connection down somewhat. But how much any particular VPN slows you down can vary enormously.

We ran all of these NordVPN vs Proton VPN speed tests with a 900 Mbps internet connection in our US lab. We tested servers in the United States and the United Kingdom, as well as Double VPN servers from each service.

Test #1: Seattle, USA

Here is a Proton VPN server in Seattle, which gave me about 699 Mbps. This is really fast and on par with our other top VPNs.

Now let’s see if NordVPN is faster than Proton VPN with this location.

Here was the NordVPN server in Seattleat 755 Mbps.

This is one of the fastest VPN speed test results we’ve gotten here on Restore Privacy. For the Seattle server location, NordVPN was 56 Mbps faster than Proton VPN.

Test #2: New York, USA

Here was the Proton VPN server in New York at about 524 Mbps.

Here was the NordVPN server in New York, giving us a speed of 613 Mbps.

It’s clear that NordVPN offers faster speeds than Proton VPN with the US servers we tested. Let’s see if overseas servers were any different.

Test #3: United Kingdom

Here was the Proton VPN server in the UK at 614 Mbps.

Here was the NordVPN server in the UK at over 593 Mbps.

For the UK region, NordVPN was slightly slower than Proton VPN. Still, both scores are really impressive, especially when you consider the high latency and long distance between my location and the VPN server. NordVPN consistently delivers on speeds and is also among the best VPNs for UK server speeds.

Double VPN speed tests with NordVPN and Proton VPN

NordVPN and Proton VPN both offer Double VPN servers. Because there are two physical servers in a Double VPN connection, they will usually be somewhat slower than a standard connection.

Note: All NordVPN users can select the Double VPN servers directly in the NordVPN app. The Proton VPN Secure Core (Double VPN) servers are only available with a paid subscription.

Here we tested a Proton VPN Secure Core server using the Switzerland > United States configuration and got a speed of 126 Mbps.

Here’s a NordVPN double-VPN server with the US > Canada configuration: 511 Mbps.

The Double VPN servers from NordVPN are significantly faster than the Secure Core (double VPN) servers from Proton VPN. This is true for other services offering double-VPN servers as well, as seen in our Surfshark vs NordVPN comparison.

How do Proton VPN speeds compare to NordVPN?

In our latest tests, Proton VPN delivered impressive speeds, closely matching those of NordVPN, though it was slightly slower on most servers. Several factors influence VPN speed, including server processing power, network bandwidth, and the physical distance between servers and users.

Despite these results, NordVPN still maintains a slight edge in speed, consistently outperforming Proton VPN and other top VPNs. This trend is also evident in our NordVPN vs. CyberGhost comparison, where NordVPN continues to lead in speed and performance.

Speed test winner: NordVPN

Proton VPN vs NordVPN streaming and torrenting

Both of these services support streaming media as well as P2P (torrenting) – but one offers a lot more streaming options than the other. Can you guess who?

Streaming with Proton VPN and NordVPN

Using VPNs to stream media is a massive, growing trend. But major streaming services like Netflix use geo-blocking technology to fence out anyone trying to connect from the ‘wrong’ physical location. Only a few VPNs have the ability to consistently defeat streaming service geo-blocking.

NordVPN Streaming

NordVPN has one of the fastest networks we’ve tested with a huge selection of streaming-compatible servers around the world.We currently rank NordVPN as the best VPN for Netflix because it offers fast and consistent access to 15+ Netflix regional libraries. Here we are streaming Netflix with a NordVPN server in the US:

Aside from Netflix, NordVPN is also a great VPN forDisney Plus, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, and more. They even offer a dedicated Amazon app if you want to use a VPN for Firestick.

Proton VPN Streaming

Proton VPN is a decent VPN for streaming, but it can’t measure up to NordVPN. Here are the streaming drawbacks we found with Proton VPN:

• Fewer streaming services supported – Proton VPN works with fewer Netflix libraries and streaming services. For example, Proton VPN only supports about four different Netflix libraries, while NordVPN officially supports more than ten.
• Restricted servers – Only Proton VPN’s paid plans support streaming. The Proton Free plan does not support streaming.

NordVPN wins the streaming challenge.

Torrenting with NordVPN and Proton VPN

What about torrenting? Can Proton VPN compete?

NordVPN – NordVPN has a lot of advantages that make it the best VPN for torrenting:

• Premium speeds (among the fastest VPNs we have tested)
• Dedicated P2P torrenting servers
• Large server network
• Secure VPN apps with no data leaks

Proton VPN – Proton VPN is a good VPN for torrenting, and they do have P2P servers. However, we found these drawbacks:

• The Free plan blocks torrenting traffic (you’ll need to upgrade your account)
• Proton VPN also blocks some servers from torrent traffic and will automatically disable your connection if they detect torrent transfers. (We’ve seen lots of complaints about this from Proton VPN users.)

Considering everything, Proton VPN does not seem to be an ideal choice for torrenting.

Note: Proton VPN now supports port forwarding. While this feature makes Proton VPN a better VPN for torrenting, we still find NordVPN to be the better choice here. We saw similar results in our Private Internet Access (PIA) vs NordVPN comparison, where even with port forwarding, Private Internet Access was slower than NordVPN.

NordVPN wins the torrenting challenge too.

Streaming and Torrenting winner: NordVPN (winner for both sub-categories)

Encryption and Security: Proton VPN vs NordVPN

Encryption and security are important factors to consider when selecting a VPN.

VPN Encryption & Protocols

Proton VPN vs NordVPN have comparable levels of encryption and protocols:

• Proton VPN: Proton VPN apps support the OpenVPN and IKEv2 protocols. For their encryption, they use AES-256-CBC and HMAC SHA-512 authentication. Proton VPN also supports WireGuard, which uses ChaCha20 for encryption.
• NordVPN: NordVPN clients use the OpenVPN and NordLynx protocols, while also supporting IKEv2 on some operating systems. For their encryption, they use AES-256-GCM with a 4096-bit DH key or ChaCha20 ciphers.

Now that Proton VPN has added WireGuard support, we consider these two VPNs to be equally secure.

Security audits

NordVPN has undergone several third-party security audits, including four different audits of their no-logs policy and implementation.

Proton VPNhas also undergone a few different security audits and three no-logs audit.

NordVPN wins. We see no reason to believe that there is anything wrong with Proton VPN’s security. And Proton VPN would win this category against most VPNs. But NordVPN simply has more audits to back them up.

VPN server security

These two companies take different tacks to provide security for their servers.

NordVPN has converted all their servers to diskless (RAM) operation. With all servers running in RAM-disk mode, it is impossible to store any data on a server. This protects NordVPN users even if a server is seized by a third party – no data will be available. We see this trend with both ExpressVPN and NordVPN, as well as a few other services moving to RAM-disk servers.

Another advantage of the NordVPN server network is that they are rolling out their own dedicated hardware. By deploying colocated servers, rather than renting servers from third parties, NordVPN will have total control over hardware. We’ve not seen Proton VPN announce the colocation of servers beyond the subset of servers that are part of the Secure Core feature. And remember that users of the Proton Free plan are blocked from access to Secure Core.

Encryption & security winner: NordVPN is the overall winner in this category.

Privacy comparison: Proton VPN vs NordVPN

What about protecting your privacy? Previously, Proton VPN had not had their no-logs status confirmed by third-party auditors. That gave NordVPN the edge in this category. However, now that Proton VPN has successfully completed a third-party audit of their no-logs policy, I have to rate this category a tie.

Prices and refunds

Okay, now that you have a sense of what each VPN is like, let’s see how much they cost and how hard it would be to get a refund if you change your mind.

Proton VPN Pricing

Proton VPN pricing has become much less complicated than in the past. While Proton VPN is not the cheapest VPN we’ve seen, their prices are reasonable. And don’t forget that the Proton Free plan lets you check out the basic service for an extended period.

Proton VPN offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, which is pretty standard in the VPN industry. We are not aware of Proton VPN offering any VPN coupons at this time.

NordVPN Pricing

NordVPN pricing gives you full access to the VPN with every pricing plan. But they now have three plans: Standard, Plus, and Complete.

The Plus and Complete plans offer additional, non-VPN features that you may well want to invest in for additional security and privacy. Whichever way you go, you will get the best current prices if you use the NordVPN discount coupon here >>

Just like with Proton VPN, all NordVPN plans come with a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Value – Is NordVPN or Proton VPN better?

Value can be subjective in that it depends on what you plan to do with your VPN.

While we don’t know exactly what you plan to do with your VPN, based on your own needs, we can compare Proton VPN vs NordVPN on three key characteristics that every user expects from their VPN: security, privacy, and speed.

So how does Proton VPN compare to NordVPN?

1. NordVPN is faster than Proton VPN.
2. Both are secure.
3. Both protect your privacy, but NordVPN offers more privacy features, diskless servers, and has four third-party audits and numerous security audits to verify its no-logs claims.

Value winner: Based on these criteria, NordVPN wins the value category as well.

Conclusion: NordVPN easily wins in 2024

Our team at Restore Privacy has always liked Proton VPN, with its strong values and privacy-focused VPN service. It’s even been featured on our best VPN list, along with the other top recommendations.However, in direct comparison to NordVPN, it’s clear that Proton VPN isn’t ready to challenge for the top spot.

We also see discussions about NordVPN and Proton VPN on Reddit, where both are liked by many readers.

Tallying up the results of our eight NordVPN vs Proton VPN test categories, we can see that NordVPN won seven out of eight.

For most users, we would recommend NordVPN over Proton VPN. It simply offers the best value for your money.

Additionally, the lackluster performance of Proton VPN really prevents us from recommending this VPN. It has a good reputation in the privacy community (Russian citizens have been known to use it to get news about the war in Ukraine), but it simply can’t compete against other leading VPN services, as we also observed in the ExpressVPN vs Proton VPN comparison.

We’re happy to recommend NordVPN, a service that continues to get better. And if you want to give it a try, use the discount coupon below for the best savings.

Want to give Proton VPN a shot? Go for it! Here is a link to their website:

Website: https://protonvpn.com/

This Proton VPN vs NordVPN comparison report was last updated on August 20, 2024.