Mistakes to Avoid When Running a Nonprofit | Bplans (2024)

A lot of work goes into making a nonprofit run smoothly, and a lot can go wrong. If you want to keep yours afloat, here are five mistakes you need to avoid.

There’s something immensely admirable about running a nonprofit; it stems from a desire to change the world for the better, and a willingness to devote oneself entirely to a charitable cause.

Unfortunately, good intentions do not a stable organization make. Business sense, logistical skill, and leadership capabilities do.

“New nonprofits face a number of significant challenges if they are to survive, and more importantly, have significant impact,”writes Wolfgang Bielefeld of Nonprofit Quarterly.“[Issues] are likely to include lack of visibility to the environment, confusion about structure, overconfident leadership, and shallow systems.”

In order to surmount those challenges and thrive, nonprofits both new and old must ensure they don’t fall into one of these five common traps encountered in their industry.

1. Under-investing in fundraising

Fundraising is a nonprofit’s lifeblood.You need to engage in it as much as humanly possible.

That means, of course, that you need to devote a fair percentage of the money you raise through fundraising toward more fundraising.

It might seem counterintuitive—greedy, even. But failure to do this can lead to the slow, agonizing death of your organization. As a matter of fact, it’s the most common reason nonprofits tend to fail, according to Joe Garecht ofThe Fundraising Authority.

“The biggest fundraising mistakes nonprofits make is underinvesting in their fundraising operations,”says Joe Garecht.“It happens year in, year out, at thousands of organizations, and it leads to the slow and painful death (or worse, the frustrating stagnation) of hundreds of charities each year.”

“For most organizations, if they are spending as much of their fundraising revenue as possible on providing programs and services, that is a good thing,” he continues. “But when you dig down deeper, the true root cause is that many nonprofits don’t place enough value in their fundraising efforts, and don’t see their development operations as an investment, instead loathing the fundraising expenses they are ‘forced’ to incur.”

In short, don’t look at fundraising as an unnecessary expenditure. Look at it as something that is integral to the growth and success of your organization—because it is.

2. Hiring the wrong people (and then failing to manage them)

Just as with traditional businesses, a nonprofit can very easily fail if it employs the wrong people.

Unfortunately, with charitable organizations, this is a far more common practice than in large enterprises. Mostly, this is because of the mentality that a dollar spent on business operations is a dollar wasted; it’s money that could have been spent on one’s cause.

“Nonprofit employers face a unique set of challenges,”writes Siobhan Kelley of The Nonprofit Times.“They are always trying to do more with less—fewer staff members, less support, less funding. A combination of these practices can result in poor employment practices, even when one thinks they are doing the ‘right thing.’”

According to Siobhan Kelley, these employment mistakes fall into the following categories:

• Poor hiring practices:You should never hire someone just to fill a position. You can’t affordnotto be picky.
• Lack ofrecord keeping:How do you know if an employee is problematic without disciplinary records? How do you keep track of promising staff without performance records, or vacation without employment records?
• Opting for salaries instead of hourly wages:In most states, nonprofit employees must be paid an hourly wage unless they meet a very specific set of criteria. This is required by law.
• Not firing problem staffers:Nonprofit employees aren’t actually all that different from staff at for-profit organizations. If they cause consistent problems and create a toxic workplace, you need to show them the door.

3. Failure to manage the legal side

In a perfect world, you’d be able to focus entirely on raising money for your cause.

You’d make a difference without having to consider your region’s regulatory environment. Unfortunately, we don’t live in a perfect world.

If you want to avoid landing in legal hot water,advises Charity Lawyer’s Ellis Carter,you need to make sure you have proper, up-to-date governing documents in place.

You need to be aware of the laws governing nonprofits, and you need to be ready to properly manage potential conflicts of interest. Most importantly, you need to be willing to step up and make difficult decisions.

4. Lacking a qualified leader (or giving a leader too much power)

Again, we need to stress here that a nonprofit is essentially a kind of business.

This means that without effective leadership, it will inevitably fail. You need to ensure you have a qualified set of executives who are willing to run things—but more importantly, you need to make sure they’re competent, and never have too much power.

“For a nonprofit organization with paid staff, once board members demand keys to the organization’s offices and start making direct demands on staff that report to the chief executive, the board has crossed the line,” says Ellis Carter. “The board’s key duties are to provide oversight and strategic direction, not to meddle in the organization’s day-to-day affairs.”

5. Missing out on marketing

Last but certainly not least, your nonprofit does not exist in a vacuum. If it’s to succeed, you need to make people aware of its existence. You need to market it.

I’m talking about maintaining awell-designed website,making effective use of social media,andestablishing a brand identityover the course of your operations. I’m talking about treating nonprofit marketing just like you’d treat for-profit marketing.

And as with every other item on this list, you cannot afford to go cheap.

“When it comes to building a nonprofit website that’s fully functional and engaging, the question should not be, ‘How much does it cost?’ The question should be, ‘What’s the return on the investment?’” says Jay Wilkinson ofFirespring.

“Your website has incredible potential and opportunity to increase donations, decrease expenses and printing costs, and engage with your audience in a meaningful way that connects them even tighter with your organization.”

See Also:How to Write a Nonprofit Business Plan

Closing thoughts

If anything, running a successful nonprofit is even more challenging than running a traditional business.

There’s so much more that can go wrong, and so many more misconceptions management must navigate around.

But the reward that comes at the end of it all is arguably well worth it—the knowledge that you’ve managed to make a difference in the world, and that you’ve managed to make it a better place.