Married Women's Projected Retirement Benefits: An Update (2024)

Introduction

The Social Security Act of 1935 provided for the general welfare of workers by establishing a system of federal old-age benefits. The 1939 amendments to the act added auxiliary benefits for women based on what was viewed as the traditional American family—men were “breadwinners”; women were wives (or widows); and husbands and wives remained married for a lifetime (Berkowitz 2002). Subsequent amendments extended benefits to divorced wives and survivors of insured workers.¹ Today, Social Security provides monthly retirement-age benefits to qualified workers and auxiliary benefits to their wives, ex-wives, and widows based on their marital histories and lifetime earnings (Social Security Administration [SSA],n.d.).²

Increasing numbers of women now receive Social Security retirement benefits based on their own earnings. Many women, however, continue to receive benefits based partly or entirely on the earnings records of their current or former husbands because their marriage-based benefits are higher than they would be if they were based solely on their own earnings records. Because benefit amounts are higher than they otherwise would be for a substantial number of beneficiaries, marriage-based auxiliary benefits have an important effect on program costs. In December2014, Social Security paid retirement-age benefits to 26.3million women aged62 or older (SSA 2016, Table5A.14). Slightly more than half of those beneficiaries (51.1percent, or 13.4million women) received benefits based on their own earnings, while the remainder (48.9percent, or 12.9million women) received benefits based at least in part on marriage.³

In December2014, about 2.3million women aged62 or older received auxiliary benefits based solely on their spouses' earnings and another 3.1million were dually entitled to both their own retired-worker benefits and auxiliary benefits. In addition, 3.7million widows received higher monthly Social Security benefits based on their deceased spouses' earnings records and 3.8million dually entitled widows received a survivor benefit that was higher than their own retired-worker benefit would have been. Thus, about 23percent of female beneficiaries aged62 or older received only wife/widow benefits and another 26percent received dual-entitlement benefits in December2014. That is a marked shift from earlier years, such as 1960, when 57percent of female beneficiaries aged62 or older received only auxiliary benefits and 5percent received dual-entitlement benefits.

Two major trends have contributed to the shift from auxiliary to retired-worker benefits for women at retirement. First, women's participation in the labor force increased dramatically after 1960 (Goldin 2006; Blau and Kahn 2007). This was particularly true for married women (Bureau of Labor Statistics 2014), including mothers of young children (Cohany and Sok 2007, Chart1). The majority of this increase occurred by the 1990s, resulting in more women in post–World WarII birth cohorts earning eligibility for Social Security retirement benefits based on their own lifetime earnings. Second, marriage trends began to change in ways that resulted in lower percentages of women born after 1945 becoming eligible for benefits as wives or widows of eligible workers (Stevenson and Wolfers 2007; Kennedy and Ruggles 2014; Tamborini and Whitman 2007; Iams and Tamborini 2012; Butrica and Smith2012).

Social Security Program Rules

This section provides a brief overview of the Social Security program rules applicable to women aged62 or older who are eligible for marriage-based retirement benefits as the wife, divorced ex-wife, or widow of an insured worker. The wife of a retired worker is eligible for a spousal benefit of up to 50percent of her husband's primary insurance amount (PIA), if claimed at her full retirement age (FRA).⁴ A wife generally must be married to the insured worker for at least 1 continuous year before she can receive benefits based on her husband's record. A divorcee may be eligible for a divorced-spouse benefit of up to 50percent of her ex-spouse's PIA if the marriage lasted 10years (120months) and the ex-spouse is alive.⁵ A dually entitled woman—who is eligible for benefits based on her own and on her spouse's lifetime earnings—receives her retired-worker benefit supplemented by the difference between that amount and the spousal benefit amount. If the wife's own retired-worker benefit is higher than her spousal benefit, she receives only her retired-worker benefit (Iams and Tamborini 2012; SSA,n.d.).

Social Security also provides auxiliary benefits to widows of insured workers. If a widow collects benefits at her FRA, her widow's benefit can equal up to 100percent of her deceased husband's PIA. A reduced benefit (71–99percent of the deceased worker's PIA) is available as early as age60 (age50 if the survivor is disabled).⁶ A divorcee with a 10-year marriage may qualify for a survivor's benefit if her ex-husband dies. (In this note, “widow” includes qualifying surviving divorced ex-wives.) If the widow benefit exceeds her own retired-worker benefit, then she is dually entitled and receives her own retired-worker benefit supplemented by the difference between it and her surviving-spouse benefit. If her own retired-worker benefit is larger than the widow benefit, then she is only eligible for her own retired-worker benefit.

Methodology

This analysis uses version7 of SSA's Modeling Income in the Near Term (MINT7) microsimulation model ⁷ to update Butrica and Smith (2012), which used MINT6 to project married women's retirement benefits. The sample population is separated into four birth cohorts: war babies (born 1937–1945), leading boomers (born 1946–1955), trailing boomers (born 1956–1965), and generationX (GenX, born 1966–1975). All Social Security benefit projections are in 2013 wage-adjusted dollars. A more detailed methodology for MINT7's projections is described in Smith and Favreault (2013b), in Butrica, Smith, and Iams (2012), and in the previous version of the estimates in Butrica and Smith(2012).

MINT7

SSA uses MINT to estimate the income, assets, and demographic characteristics of future retirees. Version7 uses data from the 2004 and 2008 panels of the Census Bureau's Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP) matched to Social Security administrative earnings and benefit records through 2010 as the basis for its projections. For individuals born from 1926 through 1979, MINT7 projects the major sources and levels of retirement income by year (through 2099), from age55 until death. Because Social Security benefits are tied closely to beneficiaries' marital events, MINT7 independently projects each person's marital changes, mortality, entry to and exit from the Social Security Disability Insurance program, and age of first receipt of Social Security benefits.⁸

MINT7 directly measures the experiences of respondents included in the SIPP interviews (2004–2010), representing the first half of the lives of leading boomers and first third of the lives of trailing boomers. MINT7 measures the changes in earnings and benefits through 2010 then statistically projects respondents' income and characteristics into the future, accounting for major changes in the growth of economy-wide real earnings, the distribution of earnings both between and within birth cohorts, and the composition of the retiree population. Those factors will all affect the retirement income of future boomer and GenX retirees. The Urban Institute performed the MINT7 calculations for this analysis under contract to SSA (Smith and Favreault [2013a, Chapter 3]) to match the procedures used for MINT6 in Butrica and Smith(2012).

Changes from MINT6

This section outlines the most important changes in MINT between versions6 and 7. For example, in MINT7, the war babies cohort includes individuals born 1937–1945, rather than 1936–1945 as in MINT6. More importantly, MINT7 uses more recent data than MINT6, with combined 2004 and 2008 SIPP panels matched to Social Security administrative earnings and benefits data through2010.

MINT inputs include projections of net immigration, disability prevalence through age65, mortality rates, and the growth in average economy-wide wages and the consumer price index (CPI). MINT7 uses projections from The 2012 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Federal Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Federal Disability Insurance Trust Funds (Board of Trustees 2012).⁹ By comparison, MINT6 used projections from the 2009 Trustees Report, which did not account for the Great Recession of 2007–2009.

MINT7 accounts for the economic effects of the Great Recession, including the decline in employment and earnings from 2007 through 2010 and subsequent slower earnings growth for the more recent cohorts. The wage-growth assumptions in MINT7 result in lower projected Social Security benefits for the more recent birth cohorts than those projected with MINT6.¹⁰

MINT7 projects that the trend observed from 2007 through 2010—an increase in the share of workers postponing retirement and a decline in the share of eligible workers claiming Social Security benefits at their earliest retirement age—will continue. MINT7 projects a smaller share of workers who will claim their benefits at age62 (one-third) than MINT6 projected (two-fifths), as well as a smaller share claiming benefits by age65 (80percent versus 90percent).

Using recent data indicating racial differences in marital histories, MINT7 estimated separate models for blacks and nonblacks to project marriage and divorce patterns overall. MINT7 projects a decrease in the share of persons who are married in future cohorts and an increasing share of women who are single at age67.

Findings

Across cohorts, the rise in women's labor force participation and earnings has increased the share of wives who are expected to be eligible for Social Security retired-worker benefits based on their own earnings (Chart1). MINT7 projects that the percentage of wives who will be eligible for retired-worker benefits based on their own earnings records will increase from 79percent for war babies to 92percent for GenXers. Because most husbands earn their own retired-worker benefits, the percentage of married couples with both spouses entitled to retired-worker benefits is also projected to rise, from 75percent for war babies to 84percent for leading boomers and 88percent for GenXers.

Similar to the earlier findings, MINT7 projects a positive correlation between husbands' and wives' lifetime earnings—one that will become increasingly positive across the more recent cohorts (Chart2). The correlation between the lifetime average indexed monthly earnings of married couples increased from about 0.17 for war babies to 0.18 for leading boomers, 0.24 for trailing boomers, and 0.28 for GenXers, indicating that the lifetime earnings of spouses have become more similar over time.

As noted earlier, auxiliary benefits provide retirement income for wives with either no earnings history or with lower earnings than those of their husbands. MINT7 projects that the growth in women's lifetime earnings will result in increasing percentages of married women receiving retired-worker-only benefits (that is, benefits based solely on their own earnings record, with no auxiliary benefit) at their take-up age (Chart3). Those percentages climb from 62percent for war babies to 73percent for leading boomers to 82percent and 81percent for trailing boomers and GenXers, respectively. MINT7 also projects cross-cohort declines in the percentages of women eligible for auxiliary benefits based solely on their husbands' earnings, from 16percent for war babies to 6percent and 7percent for trailing boomers and GenXers, respectively. As women's lifetime earnings continue to become more similar to their spouses' earnings over time, MINT7 projects that the percentage of wives who are dually entitled to Social Security benefits will decrease from 21percent among war babies to 13percent for GenXers.¹¹

MINT7 projects that many wives' or ex-wives' Social Security benefits will change—from retired-worker-only to auxiliary—when they survive their husbands or ex-husbands. A widow is eligible for a survivor benefit if her own retired-worker benefit is less than 100percent of her spouse's retired-worker benefit (before any adjustments for early or delayed retirement) (SSA,n.d.). A substantial percentage of wives are expected to receive survivor benefits that are higher than their own earned benefits, although that percentage decreases across the cohorts (Chart4). Although almost four-fifths of married women in the war baby cohort (79percent) would receive higher Social Security benefits as widows, only about two-thirds of wives in the GenX cohort (68percent) would do so. By comparison, 76percent of wives in the leading boomer and 70percent in the trailing boomer cohorts are expected to receive higher Social Security retirement benefits as widows than as spouses.

An alternative way of illustrating the relative impact of auxiliary benefits is to compare a married woman's projected actual benefits based on both her husband's and her own earnings with the projected benefit levels if they were computed on the basis of only her husband's or her own earnings (Table1). Among the GenX cohort, for example, the actual projected benefit that a wife would receive at take-up would be about $1,683 per month, on average. This benefit melds a wife's own retired-worker benefit and any auxiliary benefit. The average amount of a GenX wife's spousal benefit (based on only her husband's earnings) would be about $1,021 per month, or about 61percent of the actual benefit. The average amount based on a GenX wife's retired-worker-only benefit would be about $1,556 per month, or 92percent of the actual benefit. All of the average benefit amounts increased substantially across cohorts, especially those based on only the wife's earnings. The percentage of the actual benefit accounted for by the wife's own earnings increases from 80percent for war babies to 91percent for trailing boomers and 92percent for GenXers.

Conclusions

This note uses MINT7 to update projections of currently and formerly married women's Social Security retirement benefits. MINT7 projects that the dramatic changes in the labor force attachment and earnings of women in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries will sharply change the predominant type of Social Security benefits received by wives entering retirement. Those benefits will be determined more by wives' own lifetime earnings and less by their husbands' lifetime earnings. In contrast with the currently or formerly married women in the war baby cohort (born 1937–1945), at least four-fifths of those in the trailing boomer (born 1956–1965) and GenX (born 1966–1975) cohorts will receive their initial retirement benefits based only on their own earnings. Benefits based on wives' own lifetime earnings will account for most (91percent to 92percent) of their average total benefits. Among women who outlive their husbands, a majority will receive survivor benefits based on their husbands' earnings, although many will be dually entitled as retired workers and widows. The proportion of widows receiving retired-worker-only benefits is projected to increase from about one-fifth in the war babies cohort to about one-third in the GenX cohort.