I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner (2024)

We’ve all been told that setting, tracking, and maintaining a monthly budget is critical to financial literacy and independence, but getting started can certainly be a daunting prospect. A good old Excel spreadsheet is great for a lot of things, but when it comes to budgeting, sometimes, you just need something a bit more tailor-made for the purpose to get you where you need to be. Luckily, we live in a world where the range of budgeting and finance apps leaves us spoiled for choice, but which one is the best for you? To save you the time and effort that goes into sorting through a sea of options, I gave five different budgeting apps a try. Here’s how they ranked:

5. YNAB (You Need A Budget)

I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner (2)

YNAB, or You Need A Budget, has been around since 2004 and offers a streamlined, clean way to organize your spending. Users set their spending and saving goals and create budget categories to fit their lifestyle. While YNAB imports information from linked bank accounts, the app is still quite hands-on to ensure it is fully personalized to your needs and goals.

Personally, I found YNAB to be very similar to just using an Excel spreadsheet. It took more time than the other apps for me to set up, and I found the aesthetic to be a bit boring. However, my biggest drawback for YNAB was the cost. While the app offers users a one-month free trial, after that, it costs $14.99/month to keep using, which is expensive compared to other budgeting apps, especially when the features and usability don’t seem to stack up to the other options.

4. Personal Capital

I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner (3)

For those particularly focused on tracking investments and saving for retirement, Personal Capital is a great choice. Easy to set up, the platform provides a range of tools to monitor and manage your investment portfolio while also working as a budgeting app to help you pay down debt.

Personal Capital is perhaps best suited to the more advanced budgeters among us, as a lot of its analytical tools don’t have a lot of use unless your investment portfolio is already relatively established. Of all the budgeting apps I tried, this one was definitely the best for helping you build and track your retirement savings, which is an area often overlooked in the financial planning of young people.

Personal Capital is free to download and takes a more detailed look at your overall financial picture than a lot of the other budgeting apps. It may be a bit too in-depth or overwhelming for those just looking to manage their everyday spending and saving, but if you are interested in building your investment portfolio, this app may be the one for you.

3. Honeydue

I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner (4)

If you’re searching for a budgeting app made for couples, look no further than Honeydue. This interactive platform allows you and your partner to both access your finances, budgets, and goals and even offers a chat function so you can keep all the money talk in the app!

My favorite feature of Honeydue is that it allows you to categorize budgets as either your own personal goals or couple goals for both partners to manage together. This allows you to have transparency with your partner where a team effort is needed while also providing you with your own independence and privacy.

Another great feature of Honeydue is the shared calendar, where alerts and bills can be set to notify both partners of upcoming payments. I found this to be really helpful in making sure we both had visibility over billing dates and were able to plan our finances accordingly.

Financial security in a relationship is a team effort, and Honeydue provides the tools to manage your money collaboratively. It is free to download from the app store (though there are some ad pop-ups), and it is a fantastic option for couples looking to improve their spending habits as a team.

2. Mint

I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner (5)

I’d seen the ads for Mint on social media, so I was excited to see if it lived up to the hype. The answer? For me, Mint was definitely a standout option. Easy to use and set up for everyday budgeting, there’s no wonder Mint seems to be the app of choice for Gen Z and millennials.

The best feature for me was Mint’s customizable goals and budgets, which allow you to visually manage your spending. Much like PocketGuard, users are able to set up different goals (buy a house, go traveling, etc.), and Mint tracks your progress on little bar graphs. My only complaint about the feature is that you have to include an end date for your goal, which is a bit annoying for those of us who freelance and don’t have specified monthly payment amounts or just have longer-term goals that fit in around other things. It would be nice to fully utilize the goals system without needing to include a deadline, but regardless, the feature is a really great way for the visual users among us to keep track of savings.

Other great features that Mint offers include alerts for upcoming overdraft fees, late fees and bill payments, and the option to set up personalized spending targets for different categories.

Mint is free to download in the app store, and you can upgrade to a premium version for $4.99/month if you’re looking for more advanced updates and management, though it isn’t required to get a full experience. Overall, I found the app to be user-friendly and easy to set up, with lots of personalized features to suit each user’s situation.

1. PocketGuard

I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner (6)

Perhaps lesser known than some other budgeting apps (I personally didn’t know much about it), PocketGuard was an extremely pleasant surprise and, for me, the best app I tried out. PocketGuard is extremely easy to set up and customize, with some great features to help you feel in control of your finances. By linking your bank accounts and credit cards, PocketGuard helps you plan your savings and even has a feature to help you negotiate better rates on your bills!

The standout feature of PocketGuard is the “In My Pocket” calculation, which tells you how much money you have left over after paying all your bills and contributing to goals. This automatically tells you how much you have to spend or save for the month, which I personally found to be really helpful. PocketGuard also allows you to set up customizable goals and budgets and tracks your savings on your visual graphs. You aren’t required to set a hard deadline to meet your goals, which meant that I could visually see how I was tracking on my savings without a set monthly contribution that I knew I probably wouldn’t always meet.

While PocketGuard is free to download, some features aren’t available unless users upgrade to the premium subscription, PocketGuard Plus, which costs $7.99/month or $79.99 for a one-off payment (a great option). With the upgrade, PocketGuard offers subscription monitoring (which is amazing for those of us who have completely forgotten what we are subscribed to!) and unlimited goals and budgets. Overall, I found PocketGuard to be an amazing budgeting app, and it is definitely the one I will be keeping around for myself!

I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner (2024)

FAQs

I Tested 5 Budgeting Apps—And There Was a Clear Winner? ›

The answer? For me, Mint was definitely a standout option. Easy to use and set up for everyday budgeting, there's no wonder Mint seems to be the app of choice for Gen Z and millennials. The best feature for me was Mint's customizable goals and budgets, which allow you to visually manage your spending.

Are budgeting apps trustworthy? ›

Budget tracking apps are good for your wallet, but for your online safety, be careful with which one you pick and how you use it. June 21, 2024, at 9:32 a.m. Are Budget Apps Safe? Experts suggest researching a company before downloading their app to ensure your information is safe.

What is the #1 budgeting app? ›

The best budgeting apps: our top picks
AppCostBest for
Simplifi$47.88 billed annuallyQuicken users
Goodbudget$10 monthly or $80 annuallyThe digital envelope system
EveryDollar$12.99 monthly or $79.99 annuallyFirst-time budgeters
Monarch Money$14.99 monthly or $99.99 annuallyFinancial advisors
6 more rows

Are there better budgeting apps than Mint? ›

Empower. If you're looking for a free online budgeting tool now that Mint has shut its virtual doors, Empower may be worth considering. Formerly known as Personal Capital, Empower offers free budgeting services along with a spending tracker. The app also has investment management tools, but those services cost extra.

What are the pros and cons of budgeting apps? ›

Budgeting apps offer several benefits, from convenience and automation to goal tracking and financial insights. However, a potential learning curve and concerns about privacy and security can be drawbacks to using digital platforms for your finances.

Do budgeting apps sell your data? ›

Key insights: Nearly one-third of data collected by these apps is shared with third parties. 1 in 4 of the budgeting apps share your financial information with third parties.

Is it safe to connect your bank to a budgeting app? ›

Risk of Credentials Being Compromised

Even if you trust a particular budgeting app, you cannot guarantee that your bank password is adequately secured and protected within its systems (and its third-party data aggregators). Data breaches, hacking incidents, or even rogue employees could expose your credentials.

Is Mint still a Goodbudget app? ›

The Mint budgeting app officially shut down on March 23, 2024, and users can no longer access their data on the app. Intuit®, which owns Mint and other personal finance platforms like QuickBooks® and TurboTax®, suggested users migrate to Credit Karma, which it also owns.

Is Credit Karma a good budgeting app? ›

Credit Karma Specs

It's among the best budgeting and personal finance apps, but not our top pick. Instead, we recommend Editors' Choice winners: Simplifi, which is best for most people, Quicken Classic if you like to micromanage your money, and YNAB if you need a different way of thinking about budgeting.

What budget app doesn t connect to bank account? ›

Why we recommend it: Goodbudget is more about planning for your finances than tracking previous transactions. This app is based on the envelope budgeting system, in which you portion out your monthly income toward specific spending categories (called envelopes). This app doesn't connect your bank accounts.

Why is Intuit getting rid of Mint? ›

The reason for closing down the Mint app is the supposed consolidation of Intuit's personal finance products and to prioritize their focus on Credit Karma, which has more features and functions than Mint. However, some key features that made Mint what it is are said not to be available in Credit Karma, like budgeting.

Why is Mint shutting down? ›

In less than two weeks, the budgeting app Mint — which once had 3.6 million active users, including me — will shut down forever. According to its parent company, Intuit, Mint wasn't making enough money, so Intuit began the app's closure in January.

Is Mint going away in 2024? ›

Mint, a budgeting app acquired by Intuit in 2009, is shutting down as of Saturday, March 23, 2024. Mint shows users an overview of their financial well-being by displaying the current status of multiple linked accounts on one screen.

Can I trust budgeting apps? ›

Further, avoid using third-party money management tools, like budgeting apps, on public WiFi networks, as they tend to be less secure and could put you at risk for hacking. When using any kind of third-party tool, be sure to treat account security as a continuous and necessary step in your financial journey.

Should I use Excel or a budgeting app? ›

If you're hoping to start budgeting like yesterday, then budgeting with an app offers the advantage of being faster to get up and running. Plus, that means they're great for budgeting newbies who might not have a clear idea of where to start.

Are online budgeting apps better than paper? ›

The act of putting pen to paper can deepen the sense of ownership you have with your budget, and you could place a higher value to it than you would to a budget created with an app. This is known as the IKEA effect. It's a cognitive bias we have where we place a higher value on things that we build ourselves.

Is the Mint budgeting app safe? ›

It's secure

You should feel comfortable using Mint. Intuit uses VeriSign to securely transfer data and multi-factor authentication to protect your account.

Are expense tracker apps safe? ›

A safe expense tracker application should include elements like encryption and user checks. But always look into the app and its privacy rules before using it to make sure your personal details are secure.

What are the disadvantages of Goodbudget app? ›

Cons
  • No investing tools.
  • Limited financial reporting.
  • Bank connections are only available with premium version.
Jul 16, 2024

Are money saving apps safe? ›

Are money saving apps safe? Fintech companies take multiple security measures to protect your data. The safety of an app will vary by company, so review the terms and conditions to see if you're comfortable with the ways in which the company is handling your financial data.

Top Articles
What Everybody Needs to Know About Proper Position Sizing
Deposit Bitcoin on Cash App
jazmen00 x & jazmen00 mega| Discover
The Largest Banks - ​​How to Transfer Money With Only Card Number and CVV (2024)
Craigslist Monterrey Ca
Junk Cars For Sale Craigslist
T Mobile Rival Crossword Clue
Green Bay Press Gazette Obituary
Moviesda Dubbed Tamil Movies
Craigslist Greenville Craigslist
Zürich Stadion Letzigrund detailed interactive seating plan with seat & row numbers | Sitzplan Saalplan with Sitzplatz & Reihen Nummerierung
Kinkos Whittier
Calmspirits Clapper
Bowlero (BOWL) Earnings Date and Reports 2024
Les Schwab Product Code Lookup
Costco Gas Foster City
Osborn-Checkliste: Ideen finden mit System
Accident On May River Road Today
The Blind Showtimes Near Amc Merchants Crossing 16
Garnish For Shrimp Taco Nyt
Kingdom Tattoo Ithaca Mi
Low Tide In Twilight Ch 52
Hannaford Weekly Flyer Manchester Nh
Churchill Downs Racing Entries
SOGo Groupware - Rechenzentrum Universität Osnabrück
Safeway Aciu
Evil Dead Rise Ending Explained
Visit the UK as a Standard Visitor
Housing Assistance Rental Assistance Program RAP
Fandango Pocatello
Blue Beetle Movie Tickets and Showtimes Near Me | Regal
Pensacola 311 Citizen Support | City of Pensacola, Florida Official Website
Craigslist Boats Eugene Oregon
Pawn Shop Open Now
Insideaveritt/Myportal
Sam's Club Gas Prices Deptford Nj
Gold Dipping Vat Terraria
A Comprehensive 360 Training Review (2021) — How Good Is It?
San Bernardino Pick A Part Inventory
Silive Obituary
Craigslist Malone New York
Inducement Small Bribe
18006548818
Nu Carnival Scenes
Europa Universalis 4: Army Composition Guide
The 13 best home gym equipment and machines of 2023
Missed Connections Dayton Ohio
El Patron Menu Bardstown Ky
Model Center Jasmin
Research Tome Neltharus
Diamond Spikes Worth Aj
Mawal Gameroom Download
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Twana Towne Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 6549

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Twana Towne Ret

Birthday: 1994-03-19

Address: Apt. 990 97439 Corwin Motorway, Port Eliseoburgh, NM 99144-2618

Phone: +5958753152963

Job: National Specialist

Hobby: Kayaking, Photography, Skydiving, Embroidery, Leather crafting, Orienteering, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Twana Towne Ret, I am a famous, talented, joyous, perfect, powerful, inquisitive, lovely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.