Home News
Home Trends
By
Megan McCarty
Megan McCarty
Megan is a writer, editor, etc.-er, with over 13 years of experience in both print and digital media. She regularly contributes to design-focused outlets such as MyDomaine, Architectural Digest, Domino, House & Home, and Hunker.
Learn more about The Spruce'sEditorial Process
Updated on 07/30/24
If you're like many people, clutter happens. It may seem to crop up from one day to the next, but you should look closely at your buying habits. For many people, it's hard to pass up a great sale; some have better resistance than others.
A clear sign you need to make a change is when you're frustrated looking for space in your living quarters or can no longer "find a home" for an item. Stop buying more storage baskets to solve the problem.
Here's the best advice: Back away from the cashier, empty your online shopping cart, and try the one-in, one-out rule to keep clutter at bay and dollars in your bank account. Read on for expert suggestions on implementing this helpful rule.
What Is the One-In, One-Out Rule?
The one-in, one-out rule is just what it sounds like. Before buying any new item, you must purge a similar one you currently have.
This rule is not new; organizing teams recommend it to keep clutter in check. You can maintain order by regulating what goes in and what must come out. This natural attrition method will ensure you don't overbuy and get overwhelmed by where to put everything.
A massive accumulation of stuff can lead to disorganization and anxiety for some. Before you get overtaken by clutter, stop and mentally ask yourself: "If I get this, what will I get rid of in its place?"
Why Is the One-In, One-Out Rule Beneficial?
Following the one-in, one-out rule has several benefits. It's better for your sense of balance in the home and for keeping tabs on your bottom line. This rule forces you to confront impulse or mindless spending habits.
"We often don't realize excess is building until it is already a problem," Marissa Hagmeyer, co-founder of NEAT Method, says. "Adopting this rule can prevent clutter from accumulating over time to avoid a big editing project down the road."
The one-in, one-out rule also serves others. Should you decide it's time to get a new item—whatever it is—you can pass along the used item to friends, family, or a donation center.
"This rule keeps your life full of intentional and useful items," interior designer Andrea West says. "When something has worn out, or you are no longer using it, I love that it inspires you to donate it so that it can be used by another person who could greatly benefit from it."
How to Ensure the Rule is Effective
For this rule to be effective, the item you're replacing and its place in your home must be similar or close in size and purpose.
For example, make one-to-one swaps. An item of clothing, like a new pair of jeans, should replace another pair of jeans or pants. If you want a new set of pots, then get rid of the old ones. The space it takes up should be equal or very similar.
This rule will fail when you use the logic of one-for-one, but you're not being honest with yourself. Remain steadfast: the item should be the same—in space and function. For example, buying a new desk does not equal a planter; getting rid of a planter will hardly make a dent space-wise when purchasing a large piece of furniture.
Making the Rule a Habit
The best way to ensure success with this rule is to get yourself organized for donating by putting a system in place. Designate a drop spot in your house to collect items for donation. Next, consider the donation center you will use, and even schedule a pickup date or set the date you will drop off your items.
Also, before buying any item, think about the item you plan to donate from home before making your new purchase. If you forget to do this while at the cash register, then do it when you are unboxing or emptying shopping bags at home.
“For example, you purchase a new white v-neck, bring it home, and hang it up in your closet,” Ashley Murphy, co-founder of NEAT Method, says. “At the same time, select one top from your wardrobe to donate.”
Where Can the Rule Be Used?
You can apply the one-in, one-out rule to every room of your home. However, Hagmeyer says some spaces need more help than others. The biggest culprits are kitchens, children's rooms, closets, and houseplants.
Also, unless you live alone, you need to get others on board with the one-in, one-out rule, too.
“Don’t be afraid to involve older children in the process and make them aware in advance that they will have to say goodbye to one toy if you purchase a new one,” Hagmeyer says.