Article
IMD Professor Mike Wade talks about tech’s latest public offering
By Michael R. Wade
3 min.
March 2017
The shares of Snap will start to trade on the US markets today. The IPO price of $17 per share values the company at about $24B. Based on interest in the shares (they were ten times over-subscribed), the value of the shares, and the company, are likely to rise substantially during the day.
Does this make any sense?
On the ‘yes’ side, the price per regular user is in line with recent deals. Snapchat has about 300 million regular monthly users, about half of whom interact with the app on a daily basis. Thus, at $25B, that’s about $100 per regular user. Microsoft paid a similar price for LinkedIn last year. Facebook paid a little less per active user for WhatsApp in 2014, but it was in the same range. Unilever paid substantially more per user of Dollar Shave Club in 2016. Of course, all users are not alike, and Snapchat is extremely popular with the 13-24 crowd, and thus attractive to many advertisers. Plus, its base in North America and Europe gives it plenty of room for global expansion.
The ‘no’ side also has some strong points. When evaluated on traditional financial metrics, such as revenue (about $500m) and profit (are you joking?), the company shouldn’t be valued anything close to where it is. Plus, growth rates appear to be slowing. Competitors, like Facebook with its copycat Instagram Stories, Google, We Chat, and others, are one imitation away from stealing Snapchat’s notoriously fickle and disloyal youth audience. More disturbingly, Snapchat’s main competitors have other lines of profitable business that they can use to subsidize their attacks on Snapchat. By contrast, Snapchat, at least today, is a one-trick pony.
My biggest concern, however, is with the service itself. People use Snapchat because it is disposable – send it and it disappears. It operates with the attention span of today’s youth, i.e. none at all. Snapchat is popular largely because it is simple and fast – a quick social hit. Users don’t need to scroll though masses of irrelevant updates and holiday pics to get to the really interesting stuff. This makes the service fun to use, but it is a disaster for advertisers. People don’t go to Snapchat to search for information (like Google) to find a job (like LinkedIn), to deeply engage with friends (like Facebook), or to buy stuff (like Amazon and Alibaba). Its medium, much like Twitter, is inherently poorly designed to support advertising, and beyond this, there are no obvious sources of revenue or profit.
Would I invest in Snapchat? That depends. If I was looking for a satisfying quick hit (like I might do when receiving a Snap), then yes. If I were thinking about anything more than a few months, then no.
Michael Wade is IMD Professor of Innovation and Strategy and Cisco Chair in Digital Business Transformation.
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Technology Management
Investment
Finance
Browse all topics
Digital and AI Transformation
Related topics
Technology Management
Investment
Finance
Browse all topics
Discover our latest research
IMD's faculty and research teams publish articles, case studies, books and reports on a wide range of topics
All articles
Keep reading
Article
Impact orientation and venture capital financing: The interplay of governmental, social impact and traditional venture capital
In addition to traditional venture capital (VC), governmental VC and social impact VC investors have emerged as alternatives to fund entrepreneuria...
Finance Venture Capital Social Innovation
By Valentina Lo Mele, Anita Quas, Patrick Reichert and Stefano Romito
in Finance Research Letters
October 2024, vol. 68, 105987, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2024.105987
Read more
Article
Google’s 'search' monopoly under threat with Gen AI advent
US multinational technology and internet-related services company Google, like other such companies, is looking for ways to capitalise on generativ...
Artificial Intelligence Technology Management Change Management
By Howard H. Yu
in The National
4 September 2024
Read more
Article
責任あるAIを組織に実装する4つのステップ
In Europe, AI regulation laws have been approved, and the establishment of AI ethics and the incorporation of responsible AI into organizations hav...
Artificial Intelligence Technology Management Organizational Behavior
By Michael R. Wade and Tomoko Yokoi
in DHBR
19 August 2024
Read more
Article
What China’s fading appeal to foreign investors means for its economy
For years, the sheer size of China’s economy made it an irresistible magnet for foreign investors, with many – including sovereign wealth funds fro...
China Finance Global Business
By Simon J. Evenett
in The National
16 August 2024
Read more
Article
Cuatro claves para entender y aplicar la IA
For this tool to create value, it needs to recognise patterns and provide quality information. The artificial intelligence (AI) earthquake has take...
Artificial Intelligence Technology Management
By José Parra Moyano
in Expansión
15 July 2024
Read more
Article
Getting cybersecurity right
In the fall of 2022, an 18-year-old hacker bought stolen Uber employee credentials from the dark web. Even though they were still valid, multi-fact...
Cybersecurity Technology Management
By Öykü Işık, Dave Chatterjee and Almeida Lourenço
in California Management Review Insights Blog
8 July 2024
Read more
Impact orientation and venture capital financing: The interplay of governmental, social impact and traditional venture capital
By Valentina Lo MeleAnita QuasPatrick ReichertandStefano Romito
inFinance Research LettersOctober 2024, vol. 68, 105987, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2024.105987
Summary
In addition to traditional venture capital (VC), governmental VC and social impact VC investors have emerged as alternatives to fund entrepreneuria...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Finance
Venture Capital
Social Innovation
Browse all topics
Google’s 'search' monopoly under threat with Gen AI advent
By Howard H. Yu
inThe National4 September 2024
Summary
US multinational technology and internet-related services company Google, like other such companies, is looking for ways to capitalise on generativ...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Artificial Intelligence
Technology Management
Change Management
Browse all topics
責任あるAIを組織に実装する4つのステップ
By Michael R. WadeandTomoko Yokoi
inDHBR19 August 2024
Summary
In Europe, AI regulation laws have been approved, and the establishment of AI ethics and the incorporation of responsible AI into organizations hav...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Artificial Intelligence
Technology Management
Organizational Behavior
Browse all topics
What China’s fading appeal to foreign investors means for its economy
By Simon J. Evenett
inThe National16 August 2024
Summary
For years, the sheer size of China’s economy made it an irresistible magnet for foreign investors, with many – including sovereign wealth funds fro...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
China
Finance
Global Business
Browse all topics
How do big-ticket US subsidies affect foreign investment?
By Simon J. Evenett
inI by IMD12 August 2024
Summary
US President Joe Biden once described the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) as one of “the most significant laws” ever enacted due to its massive inves...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Geopolitics
Finance
Browse all topics
Future ready? A methodical approach will repay you
By Howard H. Yu
inI by IMD
Summary
Singapore-based DBS bank was being shaken by nimble competitors and needed to change fast. CEO Piyush Gupta knew spending big on technology wasn't ...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Agility
Business Transformation
Change Management
Competitiveness
Decision Making
Disruption
Finance
Future Readiness
Innovation
Organizational Change
Browse all topics
The critical cybersecurity lesson from the Microsoft outage
By Öykü Işık
inI by IMD19 July 2024
Summary
The IT debacle is a big reminder that cybersecurity is not just about defending against malicious attacks but also about ensuring system availabili...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Technology Management
Cybersecurity
Browse all topics
Swiss banking: In search of a secure future
By Salvatore CantalePeter NathanialandLudo Van der Heyden
inI by IMD19 July 2024
Summary
In light of the Swiss Federal government's report following the Credit Suisse debacle, how can the Swiss banking sector regain its reputation for s...
Read more
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Finance
Future Readiness
Browse all topics
Cuatro claves para entender y aplicar la IA
By José Parra Moyano
inExpansión15 July 2024
Summary
For this tool to create value, it needs to recognise patterns and provide quality information. The artificial intelligence (AI) earthquake has take...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Artificial Intelligence
Technology Management
Browse all topics
Getting cybersecurity right
By Öykü IşıkDave ChatterjeeandAlmeida Lourenço
inCalifornia Management Review Insights Blog8 July 2024
Summary
In the fall of 2022, an 18-year-old hacker bought stolen Uber employee credentials from the dark web. Even though they were still valid, multi-fact...
Contact
for additional information on IMD publications
Related topics
Cybersecurity
Technology Management
Browse all topics