- All
- Encryption
Powered by AI and the LinkedIn community
1
MAC basics
Be the first to add your personal experience
2
HMAC advantages
Be the first to add your personal experience
3
HMAC limitations
Be the first to add your personal experience
4
Digital signatures
Be the first to add your personal experience
5
Digital signature trade-offs
Be the first to add your personal experience
6
Password-based schemes
Be the first to add your personal experience
7
Password-based scheme challenges
Be the first to add your personal experience
8
Here’s what else to consider
Be the first to add your personal experience
HMAC, or hash-based message authentication code, is a widely used method to verify the integrity and authenticity of messages exchanged between two parties. It combines a secret key with a hash function to generate a unique signature that can be checked by the receiver. But how does HMAC compare with other authentication methods, such as MAC, digital signatures, and password-based schemes? In this article, we will explore the performance and security aspects of HMAC and its alternatives.
Find expert answers in this collaborative article
Experts who add quality contributions will have a chance to be featured. Learn more
Earn a Community Top Voice badge
Add to collaborative articles to get recognized for your expertise on your profile. Learn more
1 MAC basics
MAC, or message authentication code, is a generic term for any function that produces a signature based on a message and a secret key. The signature can be used to verify that the message has not been tampered with or forged by an attacker. MAC functions can be classified into two types: symmetric and asymmetric. Symmetric MACs use the same key for both generating and verifying signatures, while asymmetric MACs use different keys for each role. HMAC is an example of a symmetric MAC.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
2 HMAC advantages
HMAC has several advantages over other symmetric MACs, such as CBC-MAC, CMAC, or GMAC. First, HMAC can use any hash function as its underlying algorithm, which means it can leverage the security and performance of existing hash standards, such as SHA-256 or SHA-3. Second, HMAC is resistant to length extension attacks, which exploit the way some hash functions process messages in blocks. Third, HMAC is easy to implement and has low computational overhead, making it suitable for resource-constrained devices and applications.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
3 HMAC limitations
HMAC is not without limitations, however. One of the main drawbacks of HMAC is that it requires both parties to share a secret key in advance, which can be challenging in some scenarios, such as public key infrastructures or distributed systems. Another limitation of HMAC is that it does not provide non-repudiation, which means that the sender cannot prove to a third party that they sent a message with a valid signature. This can be problematic in legal or contractual contexts, where evidence of communication is needed.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
4 Digital signatures
Digital signatures are a form of asymmetric MAC that use public key cryptography to generate and verify signatures. The sender uses their private key to sign a message, and the receiver uses the sender's public key to verify it. Digital signatures provide non-repudiation, as the sender cannot deny having signed a message, and the receiver cannot forge a signature without knowing the sender's private key. Digital signatures also do not require a shared secret key, as the public keys can be distributed openly.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
5 Digital signature trade-offs
Digital signatures have some trade-offs compared to HMAC, however. One of the main trade-offs is performance, as digital signature algorithms are more complex and computationally intensive than hash functions. This can affect the speed and efficiency of message processing, especially for large or frequent messages. Another trade-off is key management, as digital signatures require a reliable and secure way to generate, store, and distribute public and private keys. This can involve additional protocols, such as certificates, trust models, and revocation mechanisms.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
6 Password-based schemes
Password-based schemes are another type of authentication method that use a secret password or passphrase to generate and verify signatures. The password can be derived from a user input, a random string, or a combination of both. Password-based schemes can be implemented using various techniques, such as salted hashes, key derivation functions, or password-authenticated key exchange protocols. Password-based schemes are often used for user authentication, such as logging into a website or a service.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
7 Password-based scheme challenges
Password-based schemes have some challenges compared to HMAC, however. One of the main challenges is password security, as passwords can be guessed, cracked, or stolen by attackers. This can compromise the integrity and confidentiality of messages, as well as the identity and privacy of users. Another challenge is password usability, as passwords can be forgotten, lost, or mistyped by users. This can affect the availability and convenience of message exchange, as well as the user experience and satisfaction.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
8 Here’s what else to consider
This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
Encryption
Encryption
+ Follow
Rate this article
We created this article with the help of AI. What do you think of it?
It’s great It’s not so great
Thanks for your feedback
Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.
Tell us more
Tell us why you didn’t like this article.
If you think something in this article goes against our Professional Community Policies, please let us know.
We appreciate you letting us know. Though we’re unable to respond directly, your feedback helps us improve this experience for everyone.
If you think this goes against our Professional Community Policies, please let us know.
More articles on Encryption
No more previous content
- What are the best practices and standards for PKI implementation and maintenance? 8 contributions
- How do you implement and maintain a PKI policy and governance framework for your organization? 9 contributions
- How do you evaluate and compare different encryption solutions and vendors? 8 contributions
- How do you update and revoke digital certificates in a PKI system? 10 contributions
- How do you balance encryption key management costs and benefits? 3 contributions
- How do you handle key revocation and renewal in PKI and encryption? 3 contributions
- How do you measure and report on encryption effectiveness and impact? 3 contributions
- How do you compare the performance and efficiency of symmetric and asymmetric encryption? 8 contributions
- How do you explain and demonstrate the value and benefits of encryption to your clients and stakeholders? 14 contributions
- What are the skills and qualifications required for a career in encryption and digital forensics? 2 contributions
- What are some of the challenges and opportunities of hom*omorphic encryption? 9 contributions
- How do you balance security and performance when encrypting large data sets? 3 contributions
- How do you compare and contrast block and stream encryption algorithms? 11 contributions
- How do you ensure the security and privacy of your encrypted data on a public blockchain network? 8 contributions
- What are the main components and functions of a certificate authority (CA) in a PKI system? 5 contributions
No more next content
More relevant reading
- Information Security How can digital certificates improve authentication protocols?
- Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) How do you handle SIP encryption and decryption in a multi-party scenario?
- Computer Science What is the best way to ensure that cryptographic keys are securely generated and stored in software systems?
- Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) How does RSA encryption and decryption work in TLS cipher suites?