How do you choose between insurance brokers and agents? (2024)

I agree with Orlando, there are Independent Agents who are "appointed" with more than one carrier, or can be, and what we call "Captive Agents" who only work for one carrier and whose primary allegiance is to that carrier, not the policyholder. There is a difference. Also, a broker is different than an agent.

An agent can also represent more than one company , an exclusive agent only represents one insurance company and only sells their products, an example is State Farm agent.An independent agent represents many Insuarance company s same as definition of broker.

I live in Ontario Canada. An agent is contracted with only one insurer. A broker must have contracts with at least two distinct insurers,An agent and/or a broker if they want to keep you as a client will do the best for you.Brokers can provide coverage and pricing options. Most agents cannot

Un courtier d’assurance est mandaté par les clients, il a le rôle de conseiller le client vers la compagnie d’assurance qui offre les meilleurs garanties au moindre coût tandis qu’un agent d’assurance ou agent général est mandaté par une compagnie d’assurance et ne peux vendre que les produits de cette compagnie, peut conseiller le client que sur les produits de cette compagnie mandataire. Ils ont tous les deux un rôle à jouer mais à différents niveaux.

Translated

O corretor de seguros, especialista em um determinado produto, e independente de seguradoras é o melhor amigo das empresas e famílias em vários momentos. Importante verificar as avaliações positivas no Google e na Internet, e os registros profissionais de cada profissional.

Translated

Just a side note to this. A reputable broker, will accept a "fee" in lieu of commission or clearly communicate why their is a potentially a "fee" in addition to commission (if legal in the state of operation). Ultimately, for larger business, the services provided by a broker/consultant can be substantial and the corresponding compensation for those services/work products should be negotiated, clearly understood, and mutually agreed upon.

Regardless of compensation, the principal element in the process is to listen to the client, fall back on your expertise and in tandem with the client craft a game plan. Remember the scientific method, identify a problem, form a hypothesis, create a solution, and implement same.

Knowledge. Both agent and broker should have committed to on going education.Some agency companies specialize in specific business sectors and sometime offer the best coverage/pricing combination.Brokers are only as good as the insurers they deal with. A broker can also help you find specialized or customized insurance solutions that suit your unique needs, but only if they have the insurers you need for your specific requirements.Do the agent or broker you are negotiating with have other clients in your business sector. Sector experience is important.

Ter a orientação e consultoria de um corretor pode evitar diversos problemas futuros além de criar uma relação de confiança e segurança nas contratações de seguros em geral. Uma desvantagem pode ser em relação a escolha de um profissional que não atenda as necessidades personalizadas como no mercado em geral existem bons e maus profissionais.

Translated

The AI paragraph is inept. Of course, agents or brokers get paid for their work. Working with a captive agent-employees on simple policies in many cases can work, but remember that agent represents their employer before the insured, and cannot be expected to fight for a client whose claim has been denied by his employerWorking with an independent broker means you have an advocate who knows the lingo.Insurance/Reinsurance can be complex, and requires either a specialist, or a very experienced agent/broker to properly place coverage at the best price/terms. For those deciding they can do it alone, we advise caveat emptor.

Insurance agents are contractually obligated to serve one ins co, typically. Ins brokers, generally speaking, are obligated to their client by finding the ins cos best suited to provide financial security. New ins pros most often join captive cos (State Farm, Allstate, Nationwide for example) for the in-depth training and salaries, which are less common with brokers. Over time, 5 or 10 yrs perhaps, agents may become brokers to serve a wider range of clients, for more challenging work, and work with a broad group of insurers. Ironically, captive cos don't often recommend or require their agents to join prof assocs (Big I, NAIFA, etc.). Many newer agents are not even aware that prof assocs, with support from senior members, even exist.

Agent or broker has to be committed to providing you the potential insured with unbiased professional recommendations.Including the ultimate test. Acknowledging they are NOT qualified to sell you the insurance you require

Na verdade, muitas vezes um agente ligado a determinada seguradora pode recomendar o melhor produto seguindo o seu viés de escolha baseado em metas e promoções pessoais.Importante escolher um profissional que trabalhe de forma independente de seguradoras.

Translated

I'll add that it's also good to work with a broker how you like to get services. Some brokers work in person only, some over zoom and some over the phone. For example we provide digital (zoom or phone) and no in person and we find with busy professionals this isna great solution. Also, working with a local broker is an added value though not always necessary.

To recognize a broker or agent who has voluntarily taken advanced training on complex cases, look for someone with letters after their name. These may include ARM, CIC, CLCS, CPCU, TRIP, etc.

(edited)

Agent or broker?Are they committed to ongoing education. Do they have ANY certification from National Insurance Institutes.Are they prepared to provide you with a list of current clients in your business sector that will give them a strong recommendation.Are the current staff stable or is a revolving door?Does your intuition tell you "This will be a good business and personal fit"

Um exemplo que vivemos diariamente aqui, é que nos tornamos corretores dos familiares dos nosso clientes, estabelecendo uma rede contínua de confiança e proteção.

Translated

Listo algumas ações necessárias para validar a escolha de um bom corretor, são elas: indicações e referências de amigos, familiares e empresas que se relacione; outra maneira é pesquisar em assessorias e plataformas que o mesmo seja credenciado e também verificar se possui a certificação profissional que habilite a exercer a função.

Translated

In many states, an agent is independent and represents numerous insurance companies. Some states do not even offer a broker license. Thus, looking for an insurance “broker” would be fruitless. What matters is the integrity and ethical standards of the agent/broker with whom you choose to partner. Shopping brokers rather than carriers will result in a higher premium if you frequently change carriers. Find someone you trust, and stick with them. They will be as loyal to you as you are to them. Treat your agent/broker as a partner, they will treat you the same. And fight for you with you with the underwriter accordingly. Treat them as a vendor, you will be a transaction, absent conviction. Who would you rather have? A partner, or a vendor?

Working with an insurance broker offers access to multiple insurers and unbiased advice, while a captive insurance agent represents a specific company. Brokers shop for the best coverage, whereas agents focus on their company's policies. Choose based on your preference and needs.