How Cryptocurrencies Are Taxed In India (2024)

Cryptocurrencies and non-fungible tokens (NFTs) are presently unregulated in India. While the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) had sought to ban cryptocurrencies in 2018, the Supreme Court quashed the attempted ban leaving cryptocurrencies in regulatory limbo – neither illegal nor, strictly speaking, legal. NFTs do not appear to have attracted the same level of regulatory ire as cryptocurrencies but suffer from the same uncertain legal existence as cryptocurrencies.

Featured Partner

1

Skilling

Welcome Bonus On First Deposit:

Get $30 in your verified trading account on your first deposit.

Variety:

Trade CFDs in crypto, forex, stocks, metals, commodities & more!

Invest Now

On Skillling's secure website

Please invest carefully, your capital is at risk

While there have been reports of a comprehensive Cryptocurrency Bill, no such Bill has been made public and the Government of India’s approach to cryptocurrencies remains unclear. There does not appear to be a move to substantively regulate NFTs as yet. While the Government continues to contemplate its stance on cryptocurrencies and NFTs, it has, in the interim, implemented a new tax regime aimed at taxing gains and, or, income from virtual digital assets (VDAs) – i.e. cryptocurrencies, NFTs and similar tokens, and other assets that the Government may specify. As a result, there is now a tax of 30% plus surcharge and cess on the transfer of any VDA such as Bitcoin or Ethereum under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (Income Tax Act). However, the legal position of cryptocurrencies is still unclear.

How The New Tax on Income from Virtual Digital Assets (VDAs) Works

Assets Subject to the New Tax

The Income Tax Act was amended with effect from April 1, 2022 to provide for the taxation of gains and, or, income derived from VDAs. Under the Income Tax Act, VDAs are:

  • Cryptocurrencies not being Indian or foreign currency (the proposed digital Rupee would seemingly be exempt as a result) – the specific terminology used under the Income Tax Act is “…any information or code or number or token (not being Indian currency or foreign currency), generated through cryptographic means or otherwise, by whatever name called, providing a digital representation of value exchanged with or without consideration, with the promise or representation of having inherent value, or functions as a store of value or a unit of account including its use in any financial transaction or investment, but not limited to investment scheme; and can be transferred, stored or traded electronically…”;
  • NFTs or similar tokens as the Central Government may notify; and
  • Such other digital assets as the Central Government may notify.

Curiously, the Income Tax Act does not mention either blockchain or DLT in the definition of VDAs.

The Central Government has yet to notify the NFTs, tokens or other VDAs to which the provisions of the Income Tax Act will apply. While it may, therefore, be argued that no NFTs are presently covered by the new tax regime, there is a possibility that the tax authorities will elect to tax NFTs under the cryptocurrency head as the definition includes tokens and may be considered wide enough to include NFTs. It would, therefore, be prudent for taxpayers to assume that the NFTs they acquire, sell, and, or, otherwise deal with are likely to be taxable under the regime.

When does Tax Liability Arise?

Under the Income Tax Act:

  • Where a person receives a VDA without consideration and the fair market value of that VDA exceeds INR 50,000 – the entire fair market value of the asset is considered taxable income in the hands of the person who received the VDA. The applicable rate of tax will depend on the income tax bracket within that person ordinarily falls;
  • Where a person receives a VDA for consideration lower than the fair market value, and the fair market value exceeds the consideration by more than INR 50,000 – the difference between the fair market value and the consideration paid is considered taxable income in the hands of the person who received the VDA. The applicable rate of tax will depend on the income tax bracket within that person ordinarily falls;
  • Where a person earns income from the transfer of a VDA – the income earned by that person less the cost of acquisition, if any, is subject to tax at the rate of 30%. Additionally, an equalization levy of 2% will be levied on the non-resident owner of the blockchain on which NFTs are traded.

Difficulty in Determining Fair Market Value and, or, Gains

Difficulties may arise in determining a taxpayer’s taxable income or gains from the receipt or transfer of a VDA:

Where a VDA is received without consideration or for a consideration lower than the fair market value, difficulties may arise in determining the person’s taxable income in respect of the asset. Cryptocurrencies and NFTs are generally extremely volatile with valuations fluctuating on a regular basis. Therefore, it may be difficult to pinpoint the fair market value of the asset.

Where cryptocurrency is purchased on a crypto-exchange or an NFT is purchased on a marketplace, it may generally be argued that the fair market value is the price prevailing on that exchange or marketplace at the time of the purchase.

However, this may not hold water with the income tax authorities as fair market value under the Income Tax Act is to be determined in accordance with the Income Tax Rules, 1962 (Rules). While the Rules do prescribe mechanisms for determining the fair market value of various assets, they do not specifically deal with the valuation of VDAs, thus creating a lacuna.

Problems may also arise where a person is liable to tax on transfer of a VDA. The only deduction permitted on the income earned from the transfer of a VDA is the cost of acquisition. Where a VDA is purchased and sold for an identified amount in INR or in a foreign currency, the income and the cost of acquisition are easily identifiable. However, if a VDA is acquired using, or sold in exchange for, another VDA (example an NFT is purchased using Bitcoin), the cost of acquisition and, or, consideration for the transfer of the VDA may be difficult to ascertain as a specific INR value for the acquisition and, or, transfer will not be readily available.

The difficulties in valuing VDAs for the purpose of taxation could lead to disputes with the tax authorities.

The Government has also confirmed that expenditure incurred in mining cryptocurrency is considered capital expenditure and not a cost of acquisition. Therefore, the considerable expenditure on the hardware required to mine cryptocurrency cannot be deducted from any income derived from the transfer of cryptocurrency. While no clarification is available in respect of the deduction of costs incurred to mint NFTs, these costs will likely be treated in the same manner as mining costs for cryptocurrencies.

No Set-Off or Carry Forward of Losses

The Income Tax Act expressly prohibits the set-off of losses from transfers of VDAs against income or gains derived from other VDAs. Illustratively, if a person were to sell an NFT and incur a loss, the loss cannot be set-off against a gain made on the transfer of another VDA. Illustratively, if A sells an NFT artwork for a loss of INR 10,000 and then sells units of Ethereum for a profit of INR 50,000, A would be liable to tax on the entire profit of INR 50,000 from the sale of Ethereum and would not be able to set-off the loss of INR 10,000 on the NFT.

Essentially, under the Income Tax Act, gains and income from VDAs are taxable but no relief is provided in the event losses are incurred, and, to that extent VDAs are taxed differently than most other assets in India.

What Is Tax Deducted At Source For Cryptocurrencies

The Income Tax Act further complicates matters by requiring that, where a resident transfers a VDA for consideration, the person responsible for paying that consideration must deduct 1% of the consideration at source as income tax. The requirement to deduct 1% of the consideration applies irrespective of whether the consideration is in cash, partly in cash and partly in consideration for another VDA, or in consideration for only another VDA.

The obligation to withhold tax may also be imposed on the owner of the blockchain on which NFTs are traded (whether or not they are resident in India) as they may be considered e-commerce operators facilitating the trading of NFTs.

Tax does not need to be deducted where:

  • The consideration is paid by a “specified person” and the aggregate value of the consideration being paid does not exceed INR 50,000 during the financial year; or
  • The consideration is paid by a person other than a “specified person” and the aggregate value of the consideration being paid does not exceed INR 10,000 during the financial year.

A “specified person” is defined as an individual or Hindu undivided family:

  • whose total sales, gross receipts or turnover from the business carried on by him or profession exercised by him does not exceed INR 1 crore in case of business or INR 50 lakhs in case of profession, during the financial year immediately preceding the financial year in which such VDA is transferred;
  • that does not have any income under the head “profits and gains of business or profession”.

As a consequence, tax will generally need to be deducted at source by most persons acquiring VDAs unless they fit the criteria of “specified persons” or only make purchases of VDAs infrequently and for small amounts.

Key Concerns With Tax On Cryptocurrencies

The new taxation regime introduced by the Government does not appear to take into account the nuances of cryptocurrencies and NFTs. Prior to the amendment of the Income Tax Act, experts in India and elsewhere had raised questions as to how cryptocurrencies and NFTs should be classified – capital assets, currency, securities, etc. An analysis of the nature of each category of VDAs is crucial to the formulation of a clear and effective tax regime.

  • At present, the Income Tax Act treats cryptocurrencies, NFTs and other VDAs hom*ogeneously. While both cryptocurrencies and NFTs use DLT and blockchain technology, the similarities end there. Cryptocurrencies are, by their very nature, fungible while NFTs are not. Cryptocurrencies have limited application. NFTs, on the other hand, can be deployed in a number of ways – as art, instruments, certificates of ownership, etc.
  • The fact that the Income Tax Act does not address the characteristics of VDAs and how they can be acquired and utilized could lead to confusion. Illustratively, if cryptocurrency is acquired through mining, is it considered to have been transferred to the recipient and, therefore, subject to the 30% tax? Alternatively, is it considered a receipt of a VDA without consideration making the fair market value of that VDA taxable in the hands of the miner? While experts have differing views on how the receipt of VDAs pursuant to mining will be taxed, the fact remains that the law does not address or clarify the position.
  • The new taxes imposed on VDAs appear to be aimed at discouraging investment in such assets. The tax rate of 30% – applicable irrespective of the income bracket of the taxpayer – is similar to that imposed on other assets of which the Government appears to disapprove such as lottery winnings. The refusal to permit any deductions other than cost of acquisition, or to permit the set-off of losses, and the requirement to deduct tax are further evidence of the intention to discourage investments in VDAs.
  • The Government has not prescribed the manner in which VDAs ought to be valued despite linking the imposition of tax in certain cases to the fair market value of the relevant asset. This will invariably lead to disputes and further reduce faith in the Indian tax regime.
  • Finally, the decision to tax VDAs is not indicative of the legalization of cryptocurrencies or NFTs in India. In India, assets acquired through the proceeds of crime are subject to tax. Similarly, assets acquired in an illegal fashion (benami property or undisclosed foreign assets) are also taxed. The mere incidence of taxation cannot be interpreted as legitimization or legalization of VDAs.

Examples of How Cryptocurrencies are Taxed Outside India

Other countries, particularly, in the developed world, have adopted various approaches to the taxation of VDA. Their approach appears to be predicated on how they classify VDAs.

  • Certain countries such as the U.S. consider cryptocurrencies to be property and tax gains derived from transfers. The fair value for the purposes of determining such gains is the price at which the cryptocurrency was trading on the exchange when the transaction was completed.
  • In Canada and the UK, although the two countries classify cryptocurrencies differently (as commodities and capital assets, respectively), they may be subject to both income tax and capital gains tax depending on the relevant facts and circ*mstances – example, whether the cryptocurrency was acquired through professional mining or hobby mining).

As NFTs are still a relatively new concept, many developed nations have yet to formulate specific policy for their taxation. At present, most developed nations, other than Malta, appear to tax NFTs in the same manner as cryptocurrencies. Malta has created a framework for DLT assets — which it categorizes as coins and tokens — and taxes coins in the same manner as fiat currencies and levies income tax on returns earned from financial tokens.

Featured Partner

1

Skilling

Welcome Bonus On First Deposit:

Get $30 in your verified trading account on your first deposit.

Variety:

Trade CFDs in crypto, forex, stocks, metals, commodities & more!

Intuitive & Cheap:

Designed for traders of all levels, from beginners to professionals.

Invest Now

On Skillling's secure website

Please invest carefully, your capital is at risk

What Should Investors Do?

Indian legislation in respect of VDAs is clearly still evolving. While the Government has notified the new tax regime, the regime will likely be amended over time.

  • For the present, residents looking to invest, or trade, in VDAs must familiarize themselves with the new tax regime and, ideally, consult a tax advisor before commencing such activities. Ideally, to the extent that persons would like to trade in VDAs, they should do so on exchanges or marketplaces rather than through off-market transactions. This could help substantiate the fair market value of the VDA absent guidance from the Government.
  • Taxpayers should also bear in mind the fact that their losses cannot be set-off against gains from another. Additionally, capital expenditure such as the cost of mining cryptocurrency or the cost of minting NFTs cannot be reduced from the gains made on VDAs.
  • Persons seeking to acquire or deal in NFTs will also need to be vigilant and track the Government’s actions to determine whether the relevant NFTs are considered VDAs for the purposes of the Income Tax Act.

As a legal expert specializing in taxation and regulatory frameworks, I bring a deep understanding of the intricate details surrounding cryptocurrencies and non-fungible tokens (NFTs), particularly in the context of the Indian regulatory landscape. My expertise is grounded in both theoretical knowledge and practical insights, having closely followed the developments in this field.

Now, delving into the content of the article:

  1. Regulatory Status in India:

    • Cryptocurrencies in India exist in a regulatory gray area since the Supreme Court overturned the RBI's attempt to ban them in 2018.
    • NFTs, while not facing the same regulatory scrutiny as cryptocurrencies, share a similar uncertain legal standing.
  2. Cryptocurrency Bill and Government Stance:

    • Reports mention a comprehensive Cryptocurrency Bill, but it has not been made public, leaving the government's approach unclear.
    • The absence of substantial regulations for NFTs indicates a lack of clarity in the government's stance on both cryptocurrencies and NFTs.
  3. Taxation of Virtual Digital Assets (VDAs):

    • A new tax regime has been implemented for virtual digital assets (VDAs), covering cryptocurrencies, NFTs, and similar tokens.
    • The tax is set at 30% plus surcharge and cess on the transfer of any VDA, but the legal position of cryptocurrencies remains unclear.
  4. Definition of VDAs under Income Tax Act:

    • VDAs, as per the Income Tax Act, include cryptocurrencies (excluding Indian or foreign currency), NFTs, and other digital assets specified by the Central Government.
    • Notably, blockchain and DLT are not explicitly mentioned in the definition of VDAs.
  5. Tax Liability and Fair Market Value:

    • Tax liability arises when a person receives, transfers, or earns income from VDAs.
    • Determining fair market value for VDAs, especially where received without consideration, poses challenges due to their volatile nature.
  6. Set-Off and Carry Forward of Losses:

    • The Income Tax Act prohibits the set-off of losses from VDAs against gains from other VDAs, making taxation different from other assets.
    • Losses incurred in one type of VDA cannot offset gains in another, leading to unique tax treatment.
  7. Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) for Cryptocurrencies:

    • TDS of 1% is required when a resident transfers a VDA, regardless of the form of consideration.
    • Exceptions exist for small transactions and "specified persons" with limited income.
  8. Challenges and Concerns with the Tax Regime:

    • The taxation regime appears not to consider the nuanced differences between cryptocurrencies and NFTs.
    • Lack of clarity on how VDAs should be valued may lead to disputes, and the regime seems aimed at discouraging investments in such assets.
  9. International Perspectives on VDA Taxation:

    • Different countries adopt varied approaches to VDA taxation based on their classification, with some considering them as property (e.g., U.S.) and others applying both income and capital gains tax (e.g., Canada, UK).
    • Malta stands out by creating a framework for DLT assets and taxing them differently.
  10. Guidance for Investors:

    • The evolving nature of Indian legislation regarding VDAs necessitates investors' awareness and compliance with the current tax regime.
    • Trading on exchanges or marketplaces is recommended to substantiate fair market values, especially in the absence of government guidance.
    • Investors must be vigilant about government actions, as the legal status and tax implications of NFTs may change.

In conclusion, the complex and evolving nature of cryptocurrency and NFT regulations in India requires investors and stakeholders to stay informed and seek professional advice to navigate the intricate legal landscape.

How Cryptocurrencies Are Taxed In India (2024)

FAQs

How Cryptocurrencies Are Taxed In India? ›

Cryptocurrency is a digital asset traded on blockchain. It is taxable in India with a 30% rate for gains and 1% TDS. Crypto includes Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, NFTs, and over 1,500 digital assets. Crypto transactions like trading, staking, mining, airdrops, gifts, and spending are taxable.

How is cryptocurrency taxed in India? ›

The earnings from trading, selling, or swapping cryptocurrencies are taxed at a flat 30% (plus a 4% surcharge) for both capital gain and business income. Other than this, a TDS at 1% is also applicable on the sale of crypto assets of transactions exceeding Rs. 50,000 (or Rs. 10,000 in exceptional cases).

What is the TDS on crypto in India? ›

What is 1% TDS on Crypto in India? The type of tax deducted at the transaction's source is called TDS. A 1% TDS is charged when a crypto asset is transferred. A transfer refers to a change in ownership, not a transfer from one wallet to another.

How much GST on cryptocurrency in India? ›

So, if VDAs like cryptocurrency are considered as goods, then GST can be applicable at the rate of 18%.

Is Binance taxable in India? ›

Tax on Crypto Transactions: In India, there is a 30% tax on all cryptocurrency activities like trading, mining, and exchanging. 2. TDS Requirement: A 1% Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) is applicable with a threshold of ₹50,000, and in some cases, it is ₹10,000.

How much tax do I pay on crypto gains? ›

Long-term capital gains tax for crypto

While these types of gains aren't taxed as ordinary income, you still use your taxable income to determine the long-term capital gains bracket you're in. Depending on your income and filing status, you'll generally either pay 0%, 15% or 20% on your long-term gains.

Is crypto trading legal in India? ›

RBI Circular & Supreme Court Verdict: There was a Reserve Bank of India (RBI) circular in 2018 restricting banks from dealing with crypto businesses, but the Supreme Court overturned it in 2020. Cryptocurrency isn't illegal in India, but it operates in an unregulated space.

How can I avoid 30% crypto tax in India? ›

In India, generally, gifts received are taxed except when they are received from relatives or on specific occasions. However, the person receiving the gift may not pay any immediate tax, and if he sells the crypto later, the cost basis would be the original acquisition cost, which could lower the capital gains tax.

Is TDS refundable? ›

What is a TDS Refund? If you made financial declarations at the beginning of the year, which are lower than your actual investment proofs at the end of the year, you will be eligible for a TDS refund.

What is the surcharge on crypto tax in India? ›

Therefore, regardless of whether the income is classified as capital gains or business income, the profits from buying, selling, or swapping cryptocurrencies will be subject to a flat 30% tax (plus a 4% surcharge).

How to withdraw crypto without paying taxes? ›

There is no way to legally avoid taxes when cashing out cryptocurrency. However, strategies like tax-loss harvesting can help you reduce your tax bill legally. Converting crypto to fiat currency is subject to capital gains tax. However, simply moving cryptocurrency from one wallet to another is considered non-taxable.

Is cryptocurrency legal in India in 2024? ›

Speaking at the India Today Conclave 2024, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said crypto assets cannot be legal currencies.

Can I claim crypto losses on taxes in India? ›

Any income earned from cryptocurrency transfer would be taxable at a 30% rate. Further, no deductions are allowed from the sale price of the cryptocurrency, except the cost of acquisition. Also, you cannot adjust the loss incurred from the transfer of cryptocurrency against income from any other heads.

Is it ok to use Binance in India? ›

Binance cleared to operate in India, subject to a $2.25-million fine and compliance.

Why was Binance banned in India? ›

Binance was banned in response to its non-compliance with anti-money laundering laws in the country. One of the sources quoted in the report said it was “unfortunate” that it took Binance more than two years to realise “there is no room for negotiations and no global powerhouse can command special treatment”.

Is there any tax on forex trading in India? ›

What taxes apply to forex trading? According to section 1256, 60% of your annual earnings are consistently taxed at a fixed rate of 15%. However, the remaining 40% is subject to taxation, which may vary based on your income status.

Top Articles
Making Money with a Side Hustle – The Top 15 - The Worth of Words - A Universal Blog of Life
Chartered Financial Consultant (ChFC) - Anforderungen, ChFC vs CFP - de.lutums.net
Whas Golf Card
Pet For Sale Craigslist
Places 5 Hours Away From Me
Elleypoint
Brady Hughes Justified
Botw Royal Guard
Craigslist Motorcycles Jacksonville Florida
Crocodile Tears - Quest
Rainbird Wiring Diagram
Lost Ark Thar Rapport Unlock
Dr Klabzuba Okc
Richard Sambade Obituary
Calamity Hallowed Ore
Local Dog Boarding Kennels Near Me
Nwi Arrests Lake County
Gdp E124
360 Tabc Answers
Site : Storagealamogordo.com Easy Call
How to Watch the Fifty Shades Trilogy and Rom-Coms
T Mobile Rival Crossword Clue
Obituaries Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Airtable Concatenate
Tire Plus Hunters Creek
Pioneer Library Overdrive
Jayme's Upscale Resale Abilene Photos
Doctors of Optometry - Westchester Mall | Trusted Eye Doctors in White Plains, NY
Harrison 911 Cad Log
In hunt for cartel hitmen, Texas Ranger's biggest obstacle may be the border itself (2024)
Elanco Rebates.com 2022
The Bold and the Beautiful
Japanese Pokémon Cards vs English Pokémon Cards
Grapes And Hops Festival Jamestown Ny
How To Get Soul Reaper Knife In Critical Legends
Kelley Blue Book Recalls
Myanswers Com Abc Resources
Firestone Batteries Prices
Engr 2300 Osu
The best specialist spirits store | Spirituosengalerie Stuttgart
Homeloanserv Account Login
Uc Davis Tech Management Minor
Ups Authorized Shipping Provider Price Photos
Crystal Glassware Ebay
RubberDucks Front Office
N33.Ultipro
The Cutest Photos of Enrique Iglesias and Anna Kournikova with Their Three Kids
Bf273-11K-Cl
Read Love in Orbit - Chapter 2 - Page 974 | MangaBuddy
Round Yellow Adderall
Gelato 47 Allbud
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nicola Considine CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5614

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nicola Considine CPA

Birthday: 1993-02-26

Address: 3809 Clinton Inlet, East Aleisha, UT 46318-2392

Phone: +2681424145499

Job: Government Technician

Hobby: Calligraphy, Lego building, Worldbuilding, Shooting, Bird watching, Shopping, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Nicola Considine CPA, I am a determined, witty, powerful, brainy, open, smiling, proud person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.