I’m building a new server. When I built Trump, I put 2 2TB drives into a Storage Spaces RAID-1 configuration.
That has worked well so I wanted to do the same in the new server.
But it got complicated.
When I started looking at 4TB drives for RAID configurations, I noticed terms that I didn’t recognize in the specifications: CMR and SMR.
Then I read the reviews. I got confused. Nobody seemed to like SMR drives. What were CMR and SMR? How were they different?
Conventional Magnetic Recording (CMR) drives write data on a hard disk in tracks that do not overlap. Shingled Magnetic Recording (SMR) allows tracks to overlap, which results in higher data densities, but slower read and write times compared to CMR drives.
Huh?
Just to add to the confusion, CMR is also known as Perpendicular Magnetic Recording (PMR).
This illustration begins to explain it.
Recommended by LinkedIn
The SMR technology increases the density thereby reducing the number of platters needed for a given capacity. Less platters means less cost so you know which way the industry is going.
But the SMR recording technique is accomplished by overlapping the data from one track with the adjacent tracks. Reading one track back is OK but writing one track requires rewriting the adjacent tracks at the same time.
Think about that. To write a track, the drive has to cache the new data. Then it has to read the tracks adjacent to the track needing to be written and cache that data. Then it has to merge the old data with the new data before rewriting all the tracks.
Obviously this makes writes much slower than CMR drives with discrete tracks.
For “normal” usage, these slower writes aren’t much of an issue. But in a RAID configuration, they really slow down the throughput.
So how do you know whether a given drive uses CMR or SMR?
Here’s Seagate’s status (archive.org). Here’s Western Digital’s status (archive.org). Here’s Toshiba’s status (archive.org).
It’s not easy.
Originally published at https://blog.benmoore.info.
You should never ever get any SMR drives for any purpose. The con-sides of SMR technology are way too high compared to the pro-sides (slightly more storage space).RAID usage just makes the issue more visible but after using SMR drives as regular storage devices for a couple of years, I can say "never again". The performance is all over the place and you can never know when the drive is going to stall for half a minute.If SMR drives were 3x cheaper than CMR drives, it might make sense for some use cases. Right now you get maybe 15% discount for accepting SMR and it's definitely not worth it.And if the device description doesn't clearly say CMR or PMR, you can be absolutely sure that the drive is actually using SMR and should be avoided. The marketing department knows that SMR is a negative feature so they typically "forgot" to mention it in the spec sheet.
To view or add a comment, sign in
More articles by this author
No more previous content
-
Driver User Experience
Apr 29, 2024
-
Fake “I Can’t Believe He’s Gone” Facebook Posts
Feb 19, 2024
- See AlsoIronWolfPro35 - 8TB | Seagate US
Integrity of Amazon Reviews
Feb 12, 2024
-
macOS for Windows Users
Feb 5, 2024
-
MacBrick
Jan 29, 2024
-
Say No to iOSApps
Jan 22, 2024
-
TreeSize Free
Oct 9, 2023
-
Windows Sandbox
May 1, 2023
-
New Zealand 2023
Mar 27, 2023
-
Strengthening Security
Feb 28, 2023
No more next content
Sign in
Stay updated on your professional world
By clicking Continue to join or sign in, you agree to LinkedIn’s User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy.
New to LinkedIn? Join now
Insights from the community
-
Operating Systems
What are the best ways to compare system performance across different configurations?
-
Data Management
How can you ensure data safety when changing your SATA mode to AHCI?
-
Operating Systems
How do you measure the performance of a concurrent system?
-
Information Technology
What are the most effective ways to optimize disk and file system latency in an OS?
-
Computer Hardware Troubleshooting
How do you choose the best external drive for data transfer?
-
Software Engineering
How can you design a computer system with multiple processors that maximizes performance?
-
Operating Systems
How do you monitor and troubleshoot disk mirroring and striping issues?
Others also viewed
-
The Data Center is the New Computer
Scott Schweitzer, CISSP 2y
-
Huawei Storage SmartPartition Feature Summary
Saleh Miri 1y
-
Solaris and cost-efficient removable Storage.
Harold Koenders 3y
-
Maximize Your PC's Speed with DiskTrix UltimateDefrag 6.1.2.0 Review
Roman Toro 4mo
-
NVMe (Non-Volatile Memory express) For maximum IOPS and minimum latency
Baskaran P 7y
-
Dell EMC Unity Storage Sizing
Alan Posner 5y
-
CPW Comparison POWER9 Scaleout vs. POWER7 & POWER8
Richie Palma 6y
-
How to Help Data Centre Customers Scale Faster During an On-Premise Relocation
Tony Khoury 6y
