Art is a boundless subject that has enchanted humanity for millennia, functioning as a crucial conduit for the articulation of thoughts, sentiments, and interpretations of the human experience. This intricate and multifaceted subject has spurred countless debates among philosophers, artists, and scholars, giving rise to an array of philosophical perspectives that seek to decipher its essence and purpose. In this essay, we will look on a journey to unravel five philosophies of art: Mimetic or Realism, Expressivism, Formalism, Institutional Theory, and Postmodernism. Through meticulous analysis and compelling examples, we will delve into the fundamental principles underpinning each of these philosophical frameworks, shedding light on the far-reaching implications they have for our comprehension of art’s profound significance in our lives.
Mimetic or Realism beckons us to ponder the capacity of art to imitate reality, while Expressivism emphasizes the emotional and communicative power of art. Formalism directs our attention towards the formal elements that compose an artwork, Institutional Theory examines how art is defined by cultural institutions, and Postmodernism challenges conventional notions of art by deconstructing boundaries and embracing the chaotic and fragmented nature of contemporary existence. Each of these philosophical lenses provides a unique vantage point from which we can scrutinise the intricacies of art, inviting us to traverse the diverse landscapes of human creativity and expression.
Mimetic or Realism
The Mimetic or Realism philosophy posits that art’s primary function is to imitate or represent reality faithfully. It contends that the value of art lies in its ability to capture the truth and beauty of the natural world. One of the earliest proponents of this view was Plato, who, in his work “The Republic,” criticized art for its potential to deceive and corrupt the soul.
A classic example of Mimetic art can be found in the works of the Renaissance artist Leonardo da Vinci. His masterpiece, the “Mona Lisa,” is celebrated for its meticulous attention to detail, realistic rendering of the subject, and its pursuit of capturing the essence of human beauty. Through careful observation and precise technique, da Vinci’s painting embodies the Mimetic philosophy by striving to replicate the real world with unparalleled precision.
Expressivism
Expressivism, in contrast to Mimetic philosophy, emphasises the artist’s emotional or psychological expression as the primary purpose of art. According to this view, art serves as a means for artists to convey their inner feelings, thoughts, and experiences, inviting viewers to connect with the artist on an emotional level.
An exemplary representation of Expressivism can be found in the works of Vincent van Gogh. Van Gogh’s “Starry Night” is a striking example of how art can be a direct reflection of the artist’s emotional state. The swirling, turbulent sky and the vivid, contrasting colors in the painting are believed to express van Gogh’s inner turmoil and the intensity of his emotional experiences. This painting transcends mere representation and delves into the realm of emotional expression, aligning with the core principles of Expressivism.
Formalism
Formalism, as a philosophy of art, focuses on the formal qualities of art, such as composition, colour, line, shape, and texture. It argues that the aesthetic value of art is derived from its formal elements and their arrangement, irrespective of its content or context. Formalists believe that art should be analyzed and appreciated based solely on its visual or structural aspects.
One of the most iconic proponents of Formalism is Wassily Kandinsky, a pioneer of abstract art. Kandinsky’s “Composition VII” is a prime illustration of this philosophy. The painting is a cacophony of shapes, lines, and colors that are seemingly disconnected from representational reality. Instead, Kandinsky’s focus is on the formal elements themselves and their emotional impact on the viewer. “Composition VII” invites viewers to engage with the painting on a purely visual and abstract level, exemplifying the principles of Formalism.
Institutional Theory
The Institutional Theory of art asserts that something becomes art when it is designated as such by the institutions and practices within the art world, such as museums, galleries, and critics. According to this view, the context and the role of the art world are paramount in determining what qualifies as art.
Conceptual art, exemplified by the work of artists like Marcel Duchamp, challenges traditional notions of art and aligns with the Institutional Theory. Duchamp’s “Fountain,” a urinal turned artwork, is a provocative example of this philosophy. By presenting a common, everyday object within an art gallery context, Duchamp raises questions about the role of institutions and the power of artistic intent in defining art. “Fountain” encourages viewers to reconsider their preconceived notions of art, emphasising the influence of institutions in shaping our understanding of what qualifies as art.
Postmodernism
Postmodernism, a philosophical perspective that emerged in the late 20th century, challenges traditional art conventions and questions the existence of a single, objective meaning in art. It emphasizes the multiplicity of interpretations and often incorporates elements of past styles, recontextualizing them to blur the boundaries between high and low culture.
One of the key figures associated with Postmodernism is the artist Cindy Sherman. Her series of photographs, collectively known as the “Untitled Film Stills,” explores themes of identity, gender, and the constructed nature of reality. In these staged self-portraits, Sherman adopts various personas and cinematic aesthetics to challenge the fixed notions of identity and representation. Her work embodies the Postmodern philosophy by deconstructing and reassembling familiar visual language to provoke thought and discussion.
Conclusion
Art is a realm of boundless creativity and complexity, and the philosophies of Mimetic or Realism, Expressivism, Formalism, Institutional Theory, and Postmodernism provide valuable lenses through which to understand and appreciate it. While these philosophies offer distinct perspectives on art’s nature and purpose, it’s essential to recognize that art is not confined to a single philosophy. Many artists and artworks draw inspiration from multiple philosophies or transcend categorization altogether.
The examples provided in this essay illustrate how these philosophies have been manifested in various artworks throughout history. Leonardo da Vinci’s ” Mona Lisa captures the spirit of Mimetic art through its meticulous realism, while Vincent van Gogh’s “Starry Night” embodies Expressivism with its emotional intensity. Wassily Kandinsky’s “Composition VII” showcases Formalism’s focus on visual elements, Marcel Duchamp’s “Fountain” challenges conventions in line with Institutional Theory, and Cindy Sherman’s “Untitled Film Stills” embodies the deconstructive spirit of Postmodernism.
Ultimately, these philosophies remind us that art is a dynamic and ever-evolving field that continues to push boundaries, challenge norms, and provoke meaningful discourse. By exploring these philosophies, we gain a deeper appreciation for the rich trajectory of human creativity that encompasses the world of art.
Feature Image: Death Of Socrates by Jacques-Louis David
Being Naked and Being Nude are Two Separate Things!
Smriti Malhotra
Contributor
